Technology

Why Do GTA VI Reviews Say 99 and Players Say 5.6?

The critics gave Grand Theft Auto VI a 99. The players gave it 5.6. The gap is not a mystery — the complaints are written inside the perfect scores themselves.

A Grand Theft Auto VI countdown display in an electronics store in Minsk
A Grand Theft Auto VI launch countdown display in an electronics store in Minsk. Photo: AzimsV / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0).

“At its core, GTA 6 is a pretty good game. There are large sections where it is an absolutely epic game, and large sections that are boring and too limited.” Alice Clarke wrote that for ScreenHub, the Australian site, and Metacritic gave her review an 80. It is the lowest score on the page. Every other critic score sits at 9 or 10.

152 critics had filed by the evening of November 21, and the Metacritic page showed all of them positive: a 99, with no mixed and no negative review. OpenCritic’s average sat at 98, with 100 percent of critics recommending the game. Only one other game has ever scored a 99 on Metacritic, the original Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, from 1998. Rockstar’s own line runs through the record books too: Grand Theft Auto IV took 98 in 2008, Grand Theft Auto V took 97 in 2013, Red Dead Redemption 2 took 97 in 2018. The reviews went live at 6 a.m. Eastern on November 18, the game launched at midnight local time on November 19, and Metacritic opened user reviews on November 20. By the evening of November 21, 71,576 players had rated it. Their score was 5.6. Forty-nine percent of the ratings were positive. Forty-four percent were negative.

Video Games Chronicle gave the game 5 out of 5 and still noted that it “targets 30FPS, however, in GTA 6’s densest sections, things can slow down somewhat.” The Guardian gave it five stars, and Keza MacDonald wrote, after roughly 70 hours with the game: “This can be a frustrating game at times: unpredictable, laborious, unwieldy and, occasionally, unfair.” She had pressed the wrong buttons and watched missions fail for reasons that were not always clear. The Verge published no score and called the combat clunky and the weapon wheel frustrating, with a few minor bugs along the way. Game Informer gave it 10 out of 10 and found some missions too prescriptive about where the player must go and what the player must do. IGN’s Luke Reilly gave it 10 out of 10, found the motorcycle handling stiffer than in previous games, and noted there is no way to replay a completed mission from the mission list. Kotaku’s own review called some controls cumbersome and said the second half of the story loses momentum.

Twenty-five hours in, the game starts being fun, according to the lowest score on Metacritic. Clarke wrote that the opening hours were slow and boring, with uneven writing and unskippable filler, and that the game makes Jason and Lucia eat healthy food and exercise as a chore. A player posting as VanitasFan26 on Reddit’s r/GTA6, in a post titled “I’m enjoying the game really much after 25 hours but I need to get this off my chest on the things that bothered me,” put it this way: “There is an argument to be made that they made this game like RDR 2, where it starts slow but gets better over time.” Another, No_Solid_1998, was still in Chapter 1 on November 20 and wrote: “This game is giving me Breaking bad vibes. It starts really slow, you almost give up on that, and then….. one of the best tv series of all time. I am still on Chapter 1….lets see.” A Metacritic user who scored the game 7 out of 10, killercroc458, went chapter by chapter: “Overall the game is boring because of how slow it is especially chapter 1. It starts getting better at chapter 2 but still slow and boring. Chapter 3 when you finally touch down in VICE CITY is where the real fun begins.”

Digital Foundry spent more than 100 hours testing the game on four consoles. The game renders at 1440p internally on PlayStation 5, PlayStation 5 Pro and Xbox Series X, and at 720p on the Series S. All four target 30 frames a second, with no 40 or 60 frames mode on any platform. The Pro holds 30 through around 75 hours of standard play and drops to 24 only when vehicles are destroyed with a grenade launcher. Its PSSR upscaling reconstructs the image so it convincingly passes for native 4K, and it alone gets ray-traced shadows. The base PlayStation 5 and Series X hold the target more loosely, flicking between 30 and the high 20s and dipping into the low 20s at worst. The Series S lives in a 25 to 30 frames no-man’s-land and can fall to around 20. Digital Foundry measured around 180 milliseconds of end-to-end camera movement latency on Series X, similar to Red Dead Redemption 2. On r/GTA6, in a thread titled “GTA VI is the most 60FPS-feeling 30FPS game I’ve ever played,” a player called rns926 answered the premise: “I’m in the camp that 30 FPS is fine and playable, but come on this is just some insane cope. It’s 30 FPS. It feels like 30 FPS. It doesn’t feel like 60 FPS in the slightest.” A Metacritic user who scored it 4 out of 10, winterheim_eze, asked the same question in Spanish: “¿cómo puede ser que en 2026 no pueda mantener 30 FPS?” — how can it be that in 2026 it can’t hold 30 FPS?

Rockstar opened the pre-load on November 10, nine days before launch. The download was 212 gigabytes. On a 10-megabit-per-second connection that takes more than 47 hours, according to a calculation by Deutsche Telekom. PlayStation Network buckled on the evening of November 18, with players seeing “services are busy” sign-in errors, and Sony’s status page showed all services back to normal by the morning of November 19. The PlayStation 5 version also required system software 26.07-14.23.00, about 1.2 gigabytes, before the game would start, on top of a game update of about 602 megabytes for which Rockstar published no patch notes. A digital licence check needs a working PlayStation Network connection, and some boxed copies turned out to have download codes that were already claimed. The reviewers played pre-release builds. The players got something else. In the launch-day bugs megathread on r/GTA6, a player called Upbeat-Capital3152 wrote on November 19: “PS5. My game keeps freezing and crashing. Has happened 10+ times in 3 hours of game time. It happens during cut scenes, driving, calling etc it is random. I’ve cleared cache, repaired storage, cleaned dust vents on the console but it keeps happening. Can’t play more than 10-15 mins without it crashing” Another, baccabillys69, wrote that the game “keeps crashing after an hour of gameplay. Autosave not working either, so i keep losing progress. Playing on base PS5,” and added an update: “I switched off HDR and have had no problems since.” Players also reported falling through the map, clipping through walls and furniture, cars launched into the air after collisions, and an early Lucia mission that cannot be finished after leaving a bank. From November 21, players began reporting crashes during play on PlayStation 5, with the error code CE-108255-1, and on Xbox without a comparable code.

Market research firm Sensor Tower estimates about 24.6 million digital copies had been sold by the evening of launch day, pre-orders included, for about $2.36 billion. Almost 7.9 million people were simultaneously watching others play on Twitch, YouTube and Kick, more than four times the previous record for a game launch. Grand Theft Auto V took $1 billion in its first three days in September 2013, on 11.21 million units and $815.7 million in its first 24 hours, according to Take-Two’s own announcement at the time.

The Standard Edition costs $79.99 and the Ultimate Edition $99.99, on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and S only. There is no PC version and no online mode at launch. Rockstar has announced no date for the PC version. One player in the 5.6 argued the game brought the $80 floor for game prices. In a thread comparing the critics’ 99 with the users’ score, a player called Slow_Gas_9313 wrote: “I prefer to believe the 152 review critics.” The game was finished by a studio that fired 34 workers on October 30, twelve short of the line that forces a union vote, as NILE1 reported on November 18.

Take-Two and Rockstar have disclosed no official sales figures. Sensor Tower’s estimate is the only day-one number in public, and it is preliminary.