Technology

When Hong Kong Facial Recognition Switches On Monday, What Changes?

The cameras helped solve 2,192 cases before a single face was matched. The switch-on arrives before the law, and the first private feeds come from four malls.

On Monday, Hong Kong’s police switch on facial recognition across the SmartView camera network. Commissioner Joe Chow calls it protection for law-abiding residents. The network it switches on has already helped solve 2,192 cases without matching a single face.

Hong Kong facial recognition will work in two ways, the police said at a briefing on 5 November. Officers can feed a suspect’s facial features into the system and search specified footage for whether that person appeared. Or the system can watch in real time and raise an alert when a missing person appears, and a recent photo from the family is enough to start it. Senior Superintendent Leung Ming-leung described the technology as adding “thousands of eyes” to the force, working 24 hours a day. The two examples the police give for it are both from pilot tests: a robbery suspect arrested, and an elderly man with dementia found within about 90 minutes of being reported missing.

The 2,192 cases are the number the switch-on is sold on, and they were earned before a single face was matched. The police’s own series runs 899 cases detected between the April 2024 launch and January 2026, 990 by February, 1,659 “contributed to solving” by 30 June, and 2,192 solved with 2,831 arrests by 31 October. Every figure in it predates Monday. The cameras that produced it were plain cameras: SmartView’s existing tools are crowd counting and number-plate recognition, the plate reader added in July 2025, and the only face-matching evidence in the record is the two pilot anecdotes.

The network the faces will be matched on is a HK$4.07 billion programme, and the document that authorised it says more about the wiring than the watching. The Legislative Council funding paper, FCR(2025-26)55 from March 2026, puts the communication network, the fibre linking the cameras, at HK$1.31 billion, the largest single line, and the hardware, cameras included, at HK$893 million. Running it costs HK$72.9 million this year and is budgeted to reach HK$243.1 million a year from 2036-37.

Police count about 20,000 cameras in the network now, roughly 10,000 of their own and 10,000 connected from other departments and public bodies, nearly double the roughly 11,000 there at the end of 2025. The second phase adds more than 20,000 a year, which is about one camera every 26 minutes, toward 60,000 by 2028. In a city of 7,518,300 people, that is one camera for every 125 residents. A third phase adds 6,500 more by 2031, taking the total to about 66,500.

Each search needs approval from an officer ranked inspector or above. Leung set out the test at the briefing: whether using SmartView is essential to solving the crime, how many cameras and how much footage must be reviewed, and whether that scope aligns with the investigation’s objectives. The system is restricted to four statutory purposes: safeguarding national security, preventing and detecting crime, ensuring public safety and maintaining public order. Officers must pass two internal tests before accessing footage. The procedures rest on a privacy impact assessment by an independent consultant and discussions with the privacy commissioner.

One safeguard is missing: a finished law. Commissioner Chow has said the government is developing the related legal framework for facial recognition, and the funding paper describes the new AI toolbox as enabling “early identification of persons involved in serious crime or wanted persons” without naming facial recognition at all. In the European Union, the direction runs the other way: the AI Act bans real-time remote biometric identification in publicly accessible spaces for law enforcement, with three narrow exceptions that each need prior authorisation.

Asked whether the system can identify offenders wearing masks or disguises, Chow said the force would not disclose “specific technical parameters and operational limitations”, in case criminals used the information to evade it. The police have published no accuracy rate, no matching threshold, and no procedure for handling a wrong match. Western Australia’s police published theirs when their trial ended: nine incorrect alerts out of 292, and Hong Kong’s force has published no equivalent figure.

Ordinary footage is deleted after about a month. The face data lasts longer. Images, timestamps, locations and facial characteristics captured through facial recognition are kept for up to 180 days, six times the footage’s life. The police’s reason is that the files are small and complex cases can take months to surface. Whether the 180 days covers everyone who passes a camera or only the people searched for is a question neither the police nor the privacy commissioner has answered.

The first private cameras to join the network belong to four shopping malls: Olympian City in Tai Kok Tsui, Tuen Mun Town Plaza, Kwai Chung Shopping Centre and Sierra Life in Fanling, all due to connect by the end of the year. Leung called the mall connection “merely an added bonus.” Once they do, officers can view mall footage from their offices instead of travelling to the mall and completing the paperwork to retrieve it. Security Secretary Chris Tang put it more plainly in October: the public “might not need to be told separately.” Malls must by law display signs warning that recording is in progress, but the Department of Justice advised that telling shoppers their footage feeds the police network should be voluntary, and the force says it will encourage malls to post the notice.

The privacy commissioner has said nothing in public about SmartView itself. Asked by the South China Morning Post, the office said it would not comment on individual cases and that all data users must comply with the Personal Data (Privacy) Ordinance. Its own guidance on CCTV, issued in October 2025, says facial identification and tracking “are not normally expected by the public, so their use must be supported by strong justification.” On Friday, the same office opened a compliance check on a facial-recognition entry system at Laguna City, a housing estate of 8,000 households in Lam Tin, after residents raised concerns. Laguna City’s residents can tap a card instead of showing their face.

Two weeks earlier, the city’s airport became the first in the world to be certified under IATA’s One ID standard for digital identity and biometrics, including privacy, consent and governance. Its Flight Token system has matched faces at departure checkpoints since 2021, used by more than 93 million passengers, with more than 80 per cent of departing passengers eligible.

chris_dong_dong, replying on Threads on Saturday morning to the commissioner’s announcement, wrote in Cantonese: “唔使你保障,謝。效率太低!”, which translates as “I don’t need your protection, thanks. The efficiency is far too low!” Another user, qchikk_, asked the question the police’s numbers leave open, also on Threads: “咁多CCTV又點,睇唔睇到啲騙徒🫩”, which translates as “So what if there are so many CCTVs? Can they even see the scammers?”

kk_86588, in the same thread, put the fear in the open: “香港銳眼人面識別,一定是聯合大陸所有的閉路電視人面識別系統,以維護習主席自己的國家安全。”, which translates as “Hong Kong’s Sharp Eye facial recognition must be linked with all the mainland’s CCTV facial-recognition systems, to safeguard Chairman Xi’s own national security.” It is a fear, not a fact. The police’s own list of purposes gives it its footing: national security stands first among the four. “ONLY the criminals hate it,” sarge2027dw wrote on Instagram.

The funding paper also set the procurement route: direct engagement, no open tender. The paper’s own reason is the project’s bearing on national security, the stability of its supply chain and the security of its information.