No student in England can apply for the interest-free student loan today. The University of Bristol’s finance page tells applicants the government will introduce it “from the academic year 2026/27”. That academic year began in September. The department has still not given a date. Thirteen years on.
Asha Hassan deferred her university place in the hope the loan would exist by 2016-17. She had turned her A-level grades around at college and won a place to study medicine, then felt she could not apply because of the interest problem. She told the BBC in January 2021 that many Muslim students take out a student loan “with a very heavy heart, and that also affects their studies as well”. She applied, and deferred her entry. By the time her case was raised in Parliament that July she was going into her final year. “Many miracles later, I’m going into my final year studying medicine,” she told her MP, “but it shouldn’t take miracles for a student to want to progress and use their lives to contribute to society.”
Zainab finished college the year tuition fees rose. When it became so costly, and taking out an interest-bearing loan was the only way to pay for it, she decided she could not and took a job instead. Sumaya wanted to study education and become a primary school teacher. She was offered a place, then let friends persuade her to study nursing because it was funded, and signed up through clearing at the last minute. Amina wanted physiotherapy and was unconcerned because the course was government funded. She took a year out for volunteering. The following year’s intake was no longer funded, so she was forced to give up. She would have loved to have become a physiotherapist. She has not done so.
The promise was made on 29 October 2013. David Cameron, speaking at the World Islamic Economic Forum in London, said: “Never again should a Muslim in Britain feel unable to go to university because they cannot get a Student Loan — simply because of their religion.” The 2012 fee rise had made a loan unavoidable for most students, and the interest charged above inflation meant the loan now carried riba, which Islam forbids. The government’s consultation in 2014 drew about 20,000 responses, where it usually receives 200, and 94 per cent said Muslim students needed an alternative. The model chosen was takaful, a form of group-based mutual support, and the government said the product would be ready for the academic year 2016/17.
That date was missed. A revised date followed: 2019/20. The Higher Education and Research Act 2017 gave ministers the power to introduce interest-free “alternative payments” in sections 86 and 87. The Augar review in 2019 said only that students should be able to access finance compatible with their religious beliefs. A petition in January 2021 was answered with a reference to the “complex range of policy, legal and system issues” still to be resolved. The government’s conclusion in February 2022 said it would consider “if and how” the product could be delivered through the Lifelong Learning Entitlement. The entitlement itself slipped from 2025 to courses starting in January 2027, and the department says the alternative product cannot come until the new system is in place.
The man the government asked to design the product in 2012 told Parliament in 2017 that the takaful structure had been chosen in September 2014 and would be ready for 2016/17. Dr Samir Alamad, giving written evidence, said that “if the will exists, an implementation period of 12-14 months maximum would be sufficient to deliver the TASF”, and that he was “not aware of any particular challenges or obstacles” to making it available to students sooner. Alamad told Parliament there was no exact figure for how many students the problem affected. A report published by the think tank Equi in October cited an estimate that about 6,000 students a year forgo university over interest-based loans. At that rate, thirteen years of waiting is roughly 78,000 students who never went. The Muslim Census puts the wider number affected, skipping university or paying out of pocket, at more than 12,000 a year, which over thirteen years is about 156,000. Both figures are estimates built on current rates. Neither figure comes from the department.
Under the government’s guidance, published on GOV.UK, students would apply through Student Finance England for an “alternative payment” covering tuition fees and living costs, instead of an interest-bearing loan. After leaving study they would pay contributions equal in amount and timing to ordinary repayments, based on earnings, into a takaful fund ring-fenced for future students. It would be open to any eligible undergraduate, not only Muslims, and the Student Loans Company would manage both systems. The department says students choosing it will suffer “no detriment” and experience “no advantage”. Two things are still missing: the secondary legislation to set the amount of finance and how contributions are calculated, and certification by the Islamic Finance Supervisory Board, which must be satisfied before launch.
Mukhtar Ali, who gave written evidence to Parliament in April 2026, was on Plan 2 and struggled with the decision even then. “I was on Plan 2, and even then I struggled deeply with the decision,” he wrote. “Many Muslim students either avoid university, delay their studies, or rely on family borrowing and crowdfunding to avoid taking out an interest-bearing loan.” Refusing the loan costs more than the loan. Imperial College London tells students who refuse loans for faith reasons that they are unlikely to receive money from its Student Support Fund, and that benefit assessors will count the loan as income even if it is not taken. Oxford Brookes warns that some trusts and charities exclude students who are entitled to a maintenance loan, whether they have taken it or not.
The department told The Telegraph that it was “completely false” to say the scheme would give Muslim students favourable treatment, and that nobody is excluded from university because of their faith. The Hassan sisters’ record answers that in a different register: a job instead of university, nursing instead of teaching, physiotherapy given up. On Facebook, where the Telegraph’s report was shared this week, the argument ran the same way. Of the first 100 top-level comments on one widely shared post, about 48 corrected the misunderstanding. About 27 were angry about it. “Ah yes, the great Sharia loan heist,” wrote Kamran Khan, “students repaying exactly the same amount, at exactly the same time, through exactly the same tax system as everyone else.” On the other side, Ryou Scoombs wrote: “What do you mean ‘fear of two-tier’? There literally is!” Both camps were arguing about a product that does not exist. Shab Syed, a graduate, wrote: “Fake news, I have a student loan and im paying interest always have done.”
Applications for most courses close on 13 January. The department’s April notice asking banks whether they can hold the takaful fund in a sharia-compliant account pointed to a formal tender not expected until January 2027, with contract dates from 31 August 2027, as reported by Wonkhe, and Hyphen reported that officials had been working towards the 2027/28 academic year. Whether a student who starts on an ordinary loan can switch once the product exists is still unanswered. So is the date of the secondary legislation. Both questions are open. Meanwhile the Plan 2 repayment threshold is frozen at £29,385 from April 2027 until April 2030, with interest capped at 6 per cent for 2026/27, and a Treasury Committee check in November found more than 110 university websites giving inaccurate information about when graduates start repaying and how long they repay for.
A parliamentary petition asking the government to set a firm launch date, started by consultant Haziq Hussain, had passed 1,400 signatures in August. The Federation of Student Islamic Societies said students need clarity to plan their futures.





