News

What Does Milburn’s Opportunity Guarantee Actually Guarantee?

The Jobs Guarantee goes nationwide this month, the Youth Guarantee is £820 million, and councils already owe a duty to 18-year-olds. The new law adds a promise nobody has said how to enforce.

From the end of this month, a young person who has spent 18 months on Universal Credit will be guaranteed a six-month paid job, anywhere in England, Scotland or Wales. The Department for Work and Pensions announced the nationwide rollout of its Jobs Guarantee on Saturday. More than 90,000 places are promised by March 2029, up to 25 hours a week at the relevant minimum wage. The wait falls from 18 months to 12. That starts in April 2027.

Alan Milburn told the BBC, in an interview published on Saturday, that young people deserve a legal “opportunity guarantee”, a duty on government to make sure they have a route into employment. “It should be a guarantee for a young person,” he said. “Because at the moment the only guarantee they’ve got is a very simple thing. To get a benefit. What sort of life is that?” His review publishes its final report on Tuesday. The government is expected to welcome it. A statement in Parliament comes first, then draft laws early next year.

£820 million is already committed to the promise Milburn wants to make law. The Youth Guarantee, expanded last December, offers nearly 900,000 young people a dedicated session with a work coach, 150,000 work experience placements, 145,000 training places run with employers, and 55,000 guaranteed jobs. Young people who turn the support down without good reason already face the existing benefit sanction rules, and local authorities already owe a statutory duty to support young people into education and training up to 18, including finding the ones who have dropped out.

In April to June this year, 981,000 young people were not in education, employment or training. That is 13 per cent of the age group. It is up 30,000 on the year, and the highest rate since 2014. The share of 16- to 24-year-olds in payrolled employment fell from 54.9 per cent to 50.6 per cent in the three years to last December. Apprenticeship starts for under-25s are down by more than a third since the levy arrived in 2017, and under-19 starts have nearly halved.

The Institute for Fiscal Studies, assessing the review before it is published, notes that employment schemes are often launched and wound down before anyone knows whether they have worked. Kickstart, the closest precedent, delivered 163,000 placements. The ambition was 250,000. Milburn’s case for a law is that it stops the next government quietly dropping the promise. “The system does not fail by accident, but by design,” he wrote in his interim report. “It is designed to produce qualifications rather than working adults.”

“I won’t fall into the elephant’s trap,” Milburn told Laura Kuenssberg, where a teenager could sue the prime minister for not getting the job they wanted. The duty would fall, in his words, “likely through local councils or mayors”. How it works in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland will be worked out when the draft laws are written. The duties councils already owe end at 18. The NEET rate trebles at that age.

£22 billion a year is what Milburn says the government already spends supporting young people who are economically inactive. Benefits take 25 times as much as employment support, and he wants the ratio at two to one. On his own figures, support would have to rise from under £1 billion to more than £7 billion, and benefits would fall by roughly £6.5 billion.

The Guardian reports estimates put his support package at about £6 billion. The government will not spend that much on support. The prime minister says paying for it would not mean “more money” but “spending differently”. The one support item with a reported price so far is an expansion of further education places, at £1 billion to £2 billion a year. The Mirror reports one part of the plan that does put money in young people’s pockets. Every young person on benefits would get a work allowance set at 16 hours a week at the minimum wage. Now only claimants with children or with limited capability for work get one.

The additional cost allowance that replaces PIP will go to a smaller group than the 453,000 young people currently claiming it. More than half of 18- to 24-year-olds claiming PIP get the highest award in both its parts, about £10,000 a year. That means people who cannot wash or dress themselves, or follow the route of a familiar journey without help. Only one in five was in work in 2024. The youth allowance that replaces PIP and the health element pays the standard Universal Credit rate, £338.58 a month, about £78 a week. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation says many young people on Universal Credit would be left living on about £80 a week.

About 300,000 of the young people the guarantee is for claim no benefits at all. The Institute for Fiscal Studies puts the figure at around a third of 18- to 24-year-old NEETs; the interim report puts it at about 314,000. Four in five of them in their early twenties are looking for work or volunteering. Only 2 per cent are out of work because of sickness. Around half have a degree. A guarantee that works by taking benefits away cannot reach them, because there are no benefits to take. The Youth Hubs are open to them. The written statement says so. But the Hubs are the support side, and the support side is the part with no published price.

Saul Staniforth, posting on X, put the objection in one line: “PIP isn’t an out of work benefit. Its paid to disabled people to help them cover the increased costs of being disabled, whether they are in employment or not.” Frazer Grant, a father of a 19-year-old in the age group, asked what would actually help: “More cash, someone properly in their corner to get them into work, or both?” He added that he did not want “the extra costs of disability quietly treated as unemployment”.

Saskia, who supports the plan, asked the same question from the other side: “I think it’s the right call. But will the government actually have the backbone to follow through?” And Natasha Flicksticks, replying to Staniforth, asked what happens to the students: “So will all the disabled students who rely on PIP to attend University and College have to leave their courses and sign up for Alan’s job coaching instead?”

The system should focus on helping people into work “rather than keeping them dependent on welfare”. That is Milburn’s case, as he put it to the BBC. The posts answer that the money is what makes work possible at all. PIP pays for the transport, the equipment and the care, and a guarantee of a job pays for none of it. Saskia’s doubt is the same question the review leaves open. Will the government follow through? She asks it from the side that wants the plan to work.

Milburn says his support would create 440,000 employment and education opportunities by 2036 and raise young people’s net incomes by more than £2 billion. That is 45 per cent of the 981,000 young people not in education, employment or training today, spread over ten years. The BBC’s own analysis says the plan will take as long as a decade before it makes a real dent in the benefits bill. The government’s £2.5 billion package already aims at 500,000 opportunities, and the prime minister has called the report a “watershed moment” without committing to accept it in full. Downing Street is considering whether the same overhaul should be extended to every working age. The TUC welcomed the guarantee as a “game changer”. It warned that funding it from public service budgets would be wrong.

Four in five young people not in education, employment or training say they want a job or training. Only one in five of the young people claiming PIP was in work in 2024.