News

Howard Lutnick’s Pen Has Not Signed a Name in 13 Months

The blacklist that was supposed to stop Megaspeed has not grown in 13 months. The record shows three approvals, two unsigned rules and one investigation moved out of the department.

The last name added to the Entity List went on October 9, 2025. Nothing has been added since. More than 100 candidates are waiting for review, including the Chinese AI lab DeepSeek, and the gap is the longest stretch without an addition in more than a decade. Megaspeed, the Singapore company at the center of the Nvidia scandal, is only the name on top of the pile.

The list is the Commerce Department’s main tool for cutting a foreign company off from American technology. Once a name is on it, any American supplier needs a licence from the Bureau of Industry and Security before shipping it items covered by the export rules, and those licences are reviewed under a presumption of denial. Names are added by an interagency committee. Four departments sit on it: Commerce, State, Defense and Energy. The list has existed since February 1997. Scott Bessent, the Treasury secretary, described the decision in one line on CNBC on Friday: “Commerce has the pen.”

The pen had its first chance in May. That month Howard Lutnick was among the officials who received a highly classified memo, drafted under Secretary of State Marco Rubio, warning about Megaspeed and Alice Huang, the Megaspeed executive whom American officials suspect of being a Chinese intelligence asset. Trump approved action against companies suspected of diverting Nvidia chips to China in May, according to Axios, which cited six senior sources, and the department did nothing with the approval.

The rule would have required export licences for advanced chip sales to certain countries in Southeast Asia, undoing a Biden-era rule that Nvidia and Lutnick both called too stifling. By July, Commerce staff had it ready. Every agency had signed on to it, a recently departed Commerce official told the New York Post. The official said the rule was close to being published as of July 2025, and that if it had been implemented it would have “substantially mitigated” the ability of Megaspeed and other firms in Southeast Asia to obtain Nvidia’s advanced chips. “There was a rule that was ready and all of the agencies had signed onto that rule,” the official said. “Lutnick refused to publish it.”

The email from Nvidia’s general counsel arrived in August, the same month Trump approved the crackdown a second time. Tim Teter emailed the Bureau of Industry and Security investigators handling the Megaspeed case, saying the department’s under secretary, Jeffrey Kessler, had given him permission to contact them. The investigators declined a meeting. Teter replied that he did not understand the problem, since Kessler had said Nvidia could communicate with bureau staff. When the investigators forwarded the email to Kessler, he replied within hours: “Continue to handle the case strictly according to the rules.” The Commerce Department reported the contact to law enforcement, the Justice Department asked it to stand down, and the case moved to a criminal inquiry at Justice. The investigators who had worked it for months were frustrated, according to the New York Times. Kessler did not order the investigators to disclose anything or grant a meeting, and it remains unclear whether anything else contributed to the halt.

In October, Senator Tom Cotton wrote to Lutnick asking the Commerce Department to investigate Megaspeed, which he called a spin-off of the Chinese government-owned cloud company 7Road, after a Times report on the chip flow. He wrote again at the end of the month about diversion through Malaysia. The Financial Times reported that Commerce had delayed adding Megaspeed to the list for at least two months, even though State, Defense, Treasury and Energy had all sought it.

“How come Megaspeed isn’t on the entities list?” Bessent asked Lutnick in the Situation Room on November 5, two days after the midterm elections. Lutnick replied that he did not know and would look into it, according to Axios. In the Oval Office later that day, after Trump spoke by phone with Elon Musk, the president settled it: “Let’s get it done.” Lutnick, the only holdout in the room, had warned the step would start a trade war with China. After the meeting he offered to work up some options and come back. Commerce says the confrontation never happened. “This is false. Secretary Bessent and Secretary Lutnick had no such conversation,” a department spokesperson, Kristen Eichamer, said.

A final rule signed by Kessler and filed on November 5 extends the suspension of the Affiliates Rule through January 10, 2027, Federal Register document 2026-22793. The rule, adopted in September 2025, extends Entity List restrictions to any company at least 50 percent owned by a listed party. It had been suspended since November 10, 2025, under the trade truce with Beijing. November 5 was the day Trump said “get it done,” and the day the department filed the paper that kept the second rule switched off.

Megaspeed’s balance sheet grew from $33 million at the end of 2023 to $3.0 billion a year later, according to Singapore filings cited by the short seller Culper Research. It has bought more than $4.8 billion of Nvidia chips since June 2024, according to a letter from Senators Elizabeth Warren and Chris Coons. The New York Post reported that officials learned Megaspeed had imported 50,000 more chips than Nvidia found at its Singapore data centers. The Information reported that Alice Huang procured at least $7.5 billion of semiconductors through her relationship with Jensen Huang. Nvidia itself put Megaspeed on its own prohibited trading list in June 2025 and halted new sales and shipments, a voluntary cutoff with no official American sanction behind it.

Commerce, meanwhile, approved about 24 Chinese companies to buy or handle Nvidia’s H200 chips. A Times investigation published on November 7 found two of the approved server assemblers, New Matrix and Maginfra, with empty offices and ownership links to Entity List firms Wise Road Capital and Inspur. The licences were issued while the Affiliates Rule stayed paused. In a separate procurement notice dated October 21, Northwestern Polytechnical University, which has sat on the Entity List since 2001, bought two H200 chips for 874,700 yuan, about $123,000, from a Chinese supplier that is not on the list.

Bessent went on television on Friday. He blamed the department in public. “I am frustrated when President Trump made it very clear that China should not receive any Nvidia chips above A100s,” he said. “We have all the authorities that we need. They just need to be implemented.” He also turned the question back on the company: “Did Nvidia know their client, and was there a robust effort at Nvidia to make sure that there was no leakage and that they were selling to what were obviously pass-through shell companies?” The White House had already said on Thursday that Trump “maintains complete confidence” in Lutnick.

Evan Olsen, writing on Threads on Friday, said Bessent’s job was to limit the damage to Lutnick “even though it is clear that Trump and others in his administration were also well aware of it. Lutnik needs to go, but so do many others, including Trump.” On Instagram, under the Financial Times post carrying the story, Theresa wrote: “Bessent S U C K S equally as bad as Nutlick, to be sure.” Mark Renfrow, on the same post, asked: “Why do I not believe anything this guy says?” Olsen’s version puts Trump in the room that Bessent’s account leaves him out of.

Six committees are now on the file. They span both chambers. Senate Banking Committee chairman Tim Scott has asked Jensen Huang to appear on December 3 and Lutnick on December 10, and Lutnick has agreed to appear voluntarily. Warren and Coons wrote on November 11 demanding that Lutnick, Rubio and chief of staff Stephen Miller preserve all records on Nvidia’s advanced chip exports, with the hold confirmed by November 17. Senators Ron Wyden and Representative Richard Neal opened their own investigation on November 12 into the H200 arrangement, under which Taiwan-made chips were routed through the United States for a security review with a 25 percent tariff attached, and asked whether Nvidia’s $26 million in donations to Trump projects influenced the approval. Kessler, who runs the bureau that holds the pen, was confirmed by the Senate in March by 54 votes to 45, after serving as the department’s top trade enforcement official in the first Trump administration. He was repeatedly warned about Megaspeed in deputies’ meetings, according to Axios, and each time deferred the decision. “That’s a decision for the secretary,” he said.

On November 12, Cotton wrote to Lutnick again. This time he asked the secretary to add ChangXin Memory Technologies, the Chinese memory maker known as CXMT, to the Entity List, a list that has not grown in 13 months.