News

The Brooklyn Building Collapse Sweep Has No List of the Sites It Will Check

The mayor promised sweeps of 100 sites tied to five unnamed entities. The permit files show the two contractors on this one job hold live permits at 128 addresses — and the city has not said which ones the sweep will reach.

Anthony Griggs was walking home from work when he heard two loud bangs and the building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue came down in front of him.

Eight people died in the Brooklyn building collapse, two of them children, and 18 were injured. On Thursday, Mayor Zohran Mamdani said the Department of Buildings had identified five entities tied to the construction site next door and was starting sweeps of 100 other sites connected to them. The city’s own permit records show the two firms that held permits at the lot hold live permits at 128 addresses between them, and the city hasn’t said which addresses the sweep will reach.

Novella Spence lives in a building nearby. She watched the collapse from the street and called it “catastrophic” and said “it reminds me of 9/11.” A wall of the building next door at 1323 Flatbush was torn off, leaving bedrooms and closets open to the air, and vacate orders went up for 1323, 1325 and 1327 Flatbush as well.

James Williams lived on the third floor of 1321. He was inside with his wife when the rumbling started. “All of a sudden I just saw a bright light,” he said, and then the door was open and he could see the outside. “Everybody’s traumatised, we all are,” he said. “Because one minute we’re all just living our normal lives and the next minute before our eyes this just happened, so suddenly.”

Anderson Velez, 35, was at work in the Bronx when his wife called from inside the building, under the rubble, with their children, aged 7 and 2. “She called me when the building collapsed while she was inside with rubble on top of her,” he said. “She was screaming for someone to help get my son out, and then the call cut off.” “My family, man,” he said. “Oh man. My two kids.”

Joyette Kerr stood with the families through the night and watched a survivor pulled out at 1:30 in the morning. She walked to the Bethesda Church of God across the street to sit with the widow of a young construction worker. “His wife was very hysterical,” Kerr said. “She couldn’t take the pain.” Inside the church, the Rev. Alfred Joseph, 72, heard one woman say her husband was still in the rubble. “She was not crying,” he said. “She was so quiet.” The church across the street was where the families gathered while they waited.

In June, the developer behind the lot next door, Robert Fischman, sent certified letters to the neighboring buildings saying excavation would begin within 30 days. The letter to the owner of 1321, quoted by the Wall Street Journal, promised: “All precautions will be taken to protect your property at 1321 Flatbush Avenue.” The plan was a nine-story building with 64 apartments over a supermarket, 71,388 square feet in all. The city had approved a three-story building; the nine-story plan wasn’t approved. Foundation and support-of-excavation permits went out on September 9, to the contractor Townhouse Builders, and the digging went 14 feet below grade. The last permit the city issued for the lot was a construction-fence permit to Townhouse, approved November 9 and issued November 10, the day before the building fell.

The building that fell was 96 years old, four apartments over a shop, its facade still carrying the faded letters “Ceasar Building.” The city’s housing records list 129 violations at the address, 98 of them still open, including 21 Class C, immediately hazardous, for peeling lead paint, a leaking roof and unsafe wiring. The building belonged to Isolag Realty Corp, whose head, Olufemi Falade, was jailed for 12 days in 2006 after failing to fix more than 600 violations across his buildings. A pre-construction report filed with the Department of Buildings in March described the north facade as “in poor condition with noticeable cracks identified.”

On March 20, city inspectors found demolition under way at the lot without the required overhead protection, and issued a stop-work order and a summons against the demolition contractor, N Tech Design of America. When inspectors came back on April 23, the one-story building that had still been standing in March was gone, and they issued a second summons. The Department of Buildings lifted the stop-work order in May, after deciding the problems had been fixed. The New York Post reported that one summons drew a $10,000 fine, admitted and paid; snjtoday, reading the hearing records, put the two summonses at $12,500 in total.

The engineering plans for the excavation called for steel, timber and concrete shoring, seismic monitors and crack gauges on the surrounding buildings, with visual inspections reported under a special inspector, according to Gothamist. Gothamist identified the inspector of record as MD Islam of RI Consulting Services in Queens. The foundation filing lists a special-inspection agency by number, 008904; the city hasn’t confirmed that the number is RI Consulting. The Post reported that the inspector’s license expired in July; the Department of Buildings refuted that claim, according to the New York Times. It is not publicly established whether any of the safeguards in the plans were in place when the building came down.

The mayor named no names. He said five entities tied to the construction site were associated with 100 other sites across the city, and that the Department of Buildings was starting sweeps of those sites. N Tech, which did the demolition, told CBS New York it had finished its work months ago and played no part in the excavation. In the city’s DOB NOW approved-permit records, Townhouse Builders holds permits at 36 addresses, eight of them live. N Tech Design holds permits at 296 addresses, 121 of them live. Between the two firms, that is 331 addresses and 128 with live permits. The two firms’ permits overlap at exactly one address: the lot at 2625 Bedford Avenue. The city has published neither the names of the five entities nor the list of sites its sweep will reach.

Three years ago, the corner of a seven-story building in the Bronx came down after workers removed a load-bearing masonry pier. The building was 1915 Billingsley Terrace, and the collapse was on December 11, 2023. No one died; dozens of families were displaced. The Department of Buildings’ 48-page report, published in November 2024, found that the engineer, Richard Koenigsberg, had failed to identify the pier as load-bearing. He received a two-year suspension and a $10,000 fine. The department audited his 368 facade reports from 2023, created a new proactive enforcement unit, and the City Council passed Local Law 79 of 2024, the Billingsley Terrace Structural Integrity Act.

Seven of the eight people who died have been named: Mamadou Barry, 23; José Luis Caguana Cosquillo, 26; Kevin Santiago Reyes Gonzalez, 10; Nicole Daniela Salvala Rodriguez, 9; Juan Daniel Salvada Guzman, 31; Edgar Sapon, 26; and Gabriel Siguencia, 22. The dead include immigrants from Mexico, Colombia, Trinidad and Tobago and Ecuador. The eighth, a man in his early 30s, has not been identified. Caguana, 26, leaves a son and a pregnant wife.

The Red Cross registered seven households from the building, 14 adults and five children, for emergency assistance, and opened a service center at the YMCA on Flatbush Avenue. World Central Kitchen is providing meals to first responders and to the families.

The Brooklyn district attorney’s office is looking at whether any criminal conduct contributed to the collapse. The day the building fell, someone filed a complaint with the Department of Buildings saying the collapse may have been preventable; the complaint, number 3A88671, is still active. A full stop-work order is in effect at the lot, and the site has been turned over to the Department of Buildings and the police.