News

The Leasehold Reform Bill Ends Leasehold for Flats That Do Not Exist Yet

The bill bans leasehold for flats not yet built. For the five million already leasehold, the cap is dated 2028, the conversion price is undecided, and commonhold has fewer than 20 developments in 22 years.

The Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill entered Parliament on Thursday, and the government calls it the biggest shake-up to homeownership in a century: leasehold banned for most new flats, ground rent capped at £250 a year, forfeiture abolished, and lease extensions made cheaper. The cap is the part that saves existing owners money, and it starts in 2028. The date is not in the bill. Ministers will set it by secondary legislation, and for the 5.1 million homes already leasehold, the rest of the bill is a conversion route whose price has not been set and a tenure that has failed for 24 years.

In May, the Commons housing committee said the cap should start in late 2027, with ground rents falling to a peppercorn within 20 years rather than 40. In June, after Angela Rayner led more than 80 Labour MPs in threatening to rebel, the Times reported the government was expected to pledge the earlier start. By September, Rayner told the Labour conference the cap had stalled during the change of prime minister over the summer. The bill introduced on Thursday keeps 2028 and the 40-year taper. Parliament must pass it.

Fozia Malik, an Oldham leaseholder whose case the BBC reported on Thursday, pays £150 a year in ground rent. In January it doubles to £300, on top of service charges of more than £4,000 a year. She will pay the doubled rent through 2027 and into 2028. The cap has not started. Once it does, the cap saves her £50 a year — about one per cent of a bill above £4,000. The government estimates 770,000 to 900,000 leaseholders pay more than £250 a year, and the cap cuts bills for up to one million of them. Nothing already paid comes back: the bill repays no ground rent collected before the cap takes effect.

Adam, writing on X when the cap was announced in January, said he had been unable to sell his flat for three years because lenders would not lend on a doubling ground rent. “So I have a flat that I couldn’t sell. Now I finally can after 3 years. It’s kept me from buying a house.” Joe Bovis, posting the same day, disagreed about the scale of it: ground rent was “a very minor issue”, he wrote, and “the real focus should be on service charges, which are typically much higher and tend to increase year on year.”

The bill’s escape route for existing owners is conversion to commonhold, and the threshold falls from unanimous agreement to half the leaseholders in a block. Those who do not agree stay on modified leases until they sell, so one holdout can no longer block the rest. But conversion still means buying the freehold, and the price is not set: the valuation rates will be fixed by ministers in secondary legislation, after a consultation promised in January. No rate has been set. A second bill, later in this Parliament, will set up the regulator for property agents and settle the extension rates. Homehold, which handles lease extensions, warns that until the rates are set, nobody knows how much leaseholders will save — or whether some with more than 80 years left on their leases could end up paying more.

A Threads user, _ian.robinson, welcomed the cap in January and added: “Let’s hope the freeholders don’t circumvent it with huge ‘management fees'”. In February, an X user posting as @CmdrSpace put the demand more bluntly: the profiteering from service charges and leasehold “can easily be solved with legislation, as has been done with ground rent, making profiteering from them illegal.” The bill answers that worry with powers for ministers to cap administration fees, but it does not set the cap. The service-charge reforms already switch on in phases, with new information rights in April 2027 and standardised bills in November 2027, the year before the cap arrives.

Commonhold has been tried before. It was introduced in 2004, and the government counts fewer than 20 commonhold developments in the country. The Law Commission, asked in 2020 why it had failed, gave six reasons: the law made it unworkable, mortgage lenders would not lend on it, nobody had heard of it, developers preferred the income leasehold provided, the government offered no reason to switch, and the profession simply carried on. The bill fixes the law and removes the developers’ reason by banning new leasehold. The Commission’s second reason, that lenders would not lend, is the one the bill’s passage will test.

The freeholders put a number on what the bill takes from them. The Residential Freehold Association says £18.7bn could be wiped from investments overnight, much of it money pension funds have put into ground rents, and calls the plan an “unprecedented abuse” of their rights. The government’s own impact assessment puts the loss in freeholder asset values at £27.3bn once ground rents fall to a peppercorn. A judicial review is the risk the bill carries: the select committee raised the property-rights question under the European Convention on Human Rights, and Property Industry Eye reports the cap “looks ripe for a judicial review challenge.”

Doubling ground rents were fixed once before, by a regulator. The Competition and Markets Authority spent three years chasing the clauses Taylor Wimpey had sold to 10,500 buyers, and by 2022 the developers and the firms that had bought the freeholds had agreed to strip them out and refund the rents already paid. More than 20,000 households benefited. The bill caps what can be charged from 2028 and repays nothing already paid.

Commonhold has been law in England and Wales since 2004. The Law Commission counted its failures in 2020, and the government counted its developments in January: fewer than 20. The bill now makes that tenure the default for new flats and the escape route for the rest.