News

Trump Letter to Biden Took Nearly Six Years to Surface and Its Author Is Already in Doubt

Biden called it "very generous" on his first day and then kept it private for nearly six years. The letter is two pages, handwritten in Sharpie, and his former aide says a correspondence staffer probably wrote it.

On his first day in the Oval Office, Joe Biden sat at the Resolute Desk and read the two-page letter Donald Trump had left him. He called it “very generous.” Then he refused to say another word about it for nearly six years.

Biden showed the note to some members of his staff after the inauguration, but he would not let them read it. The contents stayed private through his presidency and the first ten months of Trump’s return, until the New York Times obtained the letter this week from an excerpt of Biden’s memoir, “Promise Me, America,” which prints the Trump letter to Biden in full and comes out on November 17.

The letter is six short paragraphs, and none of them mentions the election. Trump opens on the room itself: “Coming to work every day in the Oval Office is a blessing beyond imagination. History resounds from every wall, every statue, every beautiful painting, and every corner of this magical place.” He tells Biden to take stock of “the titans who shaped the course of human events,” and that he now has “the opportunity to choose your place in history.” Then the passage every outlet quoted: “Many presidents have come and gone who simply governed as Republicans or Democrats. Largely, they did not change history, they were just swept along in its relentless tide. This will not happen to you because I know how much you love the American people.” The parts the coverage skipped are the ones in between, the weight of the job as “the anchor that grounds every decision you make,” and Biden’s strength as “your deepest reservoir of energy.” It closes “May God bless you and Jill, and may God bless America!” and is signed “Donald.”

Within hours, Alyssa Farah Griffin, who ran strategic communications in Trump’s White House, posted on X: “I would bet a large sum of money this was not written by the President, and likely not one of his speechwriters either. My guess is it was written by someone on his correspondence staff. (They send birthday wishes etc on behalf of the WH)” David Axelrod, a former senior adviser to Barack Obama, posted the same night: “What are the odds that @realDonaldTrump actually wrote this letter, eloquently lavishing praise and good wishes on the man he maintained was the beneficiary of a stolen election?” Both posts were quote-posts of the breaking-news post that carried the letter, and both appeared within hours of the news breaking.

“I’m saying Trump never wrote that letter to Joe Biden — he just signed what a publicist handed him,” wrote juliafig1 on Threads. “You will never convince me that he wrote that letter. Nor that he even read it. (I do believe he signed it, however.)” wrote editgirlnyc on Threads. “Trump wrote this as much as I wrote Macbeth,” wrote nhoj on X. The doubters argue from the words on the page, and Mehdi Hasan, posting on X, put the vocabulary at the centre of it: “There is no chance Donald Trump wrote one word of this letter. Not one. Can you imagine Trump independently deploying the word ‘resounds’?” The one dissenting voice in the threads I read was Patriot Justin, also on X, who read the doubt itself as the story: “The Trump derangement syndrome here has just reached in all new high. This man could do anything and you would say something bad about it.” The posts all appeared on November 10, the day the Times story appeared.

In September 2023, Trump gave his own account of the letter on NBC’s Meet the Press. He called it “a nice note” and said, “I took a lot of time in thinking about it.” A president can take a long time thinking about a letter someone else drafted, and he can also write it himself, and the sentence Trump actually gave does not say which of the two happened. He also said the decision to share the letter belonged to Biden.

The letter is handwritten, in Trump’s black Sharpie, on White House stationery. The Times reviewed a photocopy of the original, and the Associated Press reviewed one too. That much is not in dispute: somebody held the pen. The argument since Tuesday has been about the words, and nobody making it has stopped to separate the two jobs, composing a letter and copying it out by hand. The photocopies show two pages on White House stationery, in an envelope addressed “To 46.”

Ronald Reagan started the tradition in 1989, on a notepad headed “Don’t let the turkeys get you down,” with turkeys climbing an elephant: “Dear George, you’ll have moments when you’ll want to use this particular stationery. Well, go for it… I’ll miss our Thursday lunches. Ron.” George H.W. Bush, writing to the man who had just beaten him in 1993, kept it to the same register: “You will be our President when you read this note. I wish you well. I wish your family well. Your success now is our country’s success. I am rooting hard for you.” Bill Clinton told George W. Bush in 2001 that “the sheer joy of doing what you believe is right is inexpressible.” Bush’s note to Obama in 2009 ran 107 words and ended “God bless you. Sincerely, GW.” Obama’s letter to Trump in 2017, the longest of the set, told him “we are just temporary occupants of this office” and closed “Good luck and Godspeed.” Every one of them is short and plain-spoken. Trump’s is the most literary in diction of the seven: “History resounds,” “the titans who shaped the course of human events,” “relentless tide,” “deepest reservoir of energy.” That diction is the whole of the case against him. Obama didn’t tell even his closest aides what he wrote to Trump; CNN obtained the letter from a visitor Trump showed it to.

Four years later, Biden left Trump a letter of his own. Trump found it on camera on January 20, 2025, only after a reporter asked whether Biden had left one, and pulled the envelope marked “47” from a drawer of the Resolute Desk while he was signing executive orders. It reads, in full: “Dear President Trump, As I take leave of this sacred office I wish you and your family all the best in the next four years. The American people — and people around the world — look to this house for steadiness in the inevitable storms of history, and my prayer is that in the coming years will be a time of prosperity, peace, and grace for our nation. May God bless you and guide you as He has blessed and guided our beloved country since our founding. Joe Biden.” Fox News had the text within two days, and Trump called it “very nice” and “a little bit of an inspirational-type letter.” The 2025 letter reached the public within two days of being found, and the 2021 letter took nearly six years.

The first excerpt from the memoir, published by The Atlantic on November 9, carries Biden’s account of January 6: “Donald Trump led an insurrection,” he wrote, and “What Trump did on January 6, 2021, should never be forgotten. It should follow him to his grave.” The same excerpt recounts the “traditional meeting” Biden held with Trump after the 2024 election, the one in the photograph from November 13, 2024, where Trump told him, “You know, Joe, if it weren’t for politics, I believe we’d be good friends.” Biden wrote that he blinked, “too stunned to respond.” The letter arrived in the second excerpt, on November 10. The White House answered that one with a statement from communications director Steven Cheung, who said: “Joe Biden should have heeded the president’s wise words, but instead he tried to destroy this country and weaponize the justice system against his political enemies. Biden is a disgrace, and America is better off with him no longer as president.” The White House also confirmed to NewsNation that the letter is real, two days after the memoir excerpt appeared.

Bush’s note to Clinton has been held up as the tradition’s model of grace in defeat, and it gained new attention on social media after the 2020 election. Hillary Clinton posted a photograph of it on Instagram in 2016, recalling that it had moved her to tears when she and her husband found it in the Oval Office on their first day.