Energy

The Rosebank Oil Field Decision Belongs to One Minister, Not the Cabinet

The law says one woman decides Rosebank on the evidence alone. The Budget counts its tax, the cabinet lobbies for it, and her own Jackdaw decision shows she could not confidently value what is at stake.

“I cannot and will not undermine the regulatory process that is currently under way by discussing the merits or demerits of the Rosebank project today.” The minister said that in Westminster Hall on Wednesday, at the start of a debate about the largest undeveloped oil field in British waters. The room then spent the afternoon doing exactly what she had refused to do.

That refusal is the story of Rosebank, and it is not a courtesy. The Rosebank oil field decision is quasi-judicial. One woman, the energy secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh, decides it on the evidence alone, and the law says the rest of Westminster, the cabinet, the Treasury and the protesters outside MPs’ offices, does not get a vote. The decision is due by the end of the year.

In the Lords, on 29 October, a minister gave her word for it. “I can absolutely guarantee, because I know the Energy Secretary very well, that she has not made the decision, she will make the decision on the facts, and the Government will stand by that decision.” The guarantee came with a warning from the benches: if the decision were made “on a political basis and not on the facts for and against going ahead, there could be another legal challenge, which would delay it for a further two years”. The minister agreed. The factors, she said, “will be — and must be — taken into account. If not, they are bound to be legally challenged.”

The word itself is contested in the chamber. One peer told the minister it “cannot be regarded as quasi-judicial” at all: a judicial decision was made in the Scottish courts about a year ago, and the government’s duty is to make a factual decision taking that judgment into account. Lord Carlile, who has taken quasi-judicial decisions himself, called the label “a quasi-excuse” and said they “do not need to take a year”. The minister’s answer was that officials had told her “categorically” the decision is quasi-judicial “because, given the range of factors that the Secretary of State has to take into account on this, it could be opened up to a court challenge.”

The court challenge is the reason the file exists in its current form. In June 2024 the Supreme Court ruled in Finch that the emissions from burning extracted fuel (scope 3, the oil and gas once it is used) must be assessed before a development is approved. In January 2025 the Court of Session agreed that the original Rosebank and Jackdaw consents were unlawful for failing to do that assessment, and suspended the revocations until the decisions were made again. Preparatory work could continue. No oil could be extracted until new consents were granted. Adura, the Shell-Equinor joint venture that operates both fields, resubmitted further information in June 2026, and a parliamentary written answer on 12 November confirmed the publication of the new material. The Jackdaw re-determination came first, and it is the only record of how Fahnbulleh actually weighs a field.

Her decision document on Jackdaw runs to 92 pages, dated 14 October, and it weighs everything in the open. The field’s greenhouse gas emissions, including the gas once it is burned, are “likely to have a significant effect on the environment”, and she gave them “moderate adverse weight”, using the highest production case, assuming every hydrocarbon extracted is combusted, and assuming no substitution at all. The totals are about 36.6 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent over the field’s life, around 30.5 million of it from burning the gas. Energy security got “significant positive weight”. Jobs got “moderate positive weight”, on the developer’s own figures: 27 new direct jobs, and 273 existing jobs at the Shearwater platform that would otherwise be lost when it ceased to operate. The document notes, in the same paragraph, that “the number of direct jobs is small in the context of the national economy”. The UK’s standing as a climate leader got “moderate adverse weight”. Other economic benefits got “moderate positive weight”. A consultee’s estimate putting the climate damage at over £16.1 billion, several times the claimed lifetime economic value, was set aside as speculative.

Two lines in the document matter more than the weights, because they are the two things everyone outside the room argues about. On bills: “Jackdaw will not materially affect energy prices or consumer bills as the UK is a price-taker in global oil and gas markets. She therefore gives this factor negligible weight in the decision.” On tax: “related to forecasting tax receipts, the SoS has not been able to form a view in which she has sufficient confidence. Therefore, she has considered it as a material consideration but gives negligible weight to potential tax receipts.” The same tax passage records representations putting the tax relief for Rosebank and Jackdaw together at nearly £4 billion, roughly matching, or even exceeding, the expected tax revenue. The North Sea Transition Authority granted consent for Jackdaw on 21 October. Gas was flowing by the end of the month.

Rosebank is the same test at roughly seven times the scale. A Liberal Democrat in Wednesday’s debate put its scope 3 emissions at about seven times Jackdaw’s, and about a quarter of the UK’s sixth carbon budget. Carla Denyer, the Green MP who secured the debate, put the figure at 254 million tonnes, 70 percent of the UK’s annual emissions, more than the combined carbon dioxide of the 73 lowest-emitting countries. Production would run until 2052. She also told the room that ministers had held 200 meetings with Rosebank and Jackdaw firms and lobbyists between July 2024 and June 2026, about two a week, and that Shell’s global profits had doubled to £8.1 billion in the year to September 2025. Her own line from Fahnbulleh, quoted back at the minister: “if you care about affordability, North Sea does not solve that problem for you.”

The Budget, meanwhile, has already counted the money. The Office for Budget Responsibility’s economic and fiscal outlook, published on 28 October, says its projection of oil and gas receipts “includes production from currently producing fields (including Jackdaw), and the NSTA’s estimate of production from development of new fields, which includes Rosebank”. The figures are £5.1 billion in 2026-27, £1.9 billion by 2028-29, £300 million in 2030-31, and “close to zero in 2031-32”, when the windfall tax expires in September 2029. Rosebank has been in the forecast since at least 2019. Without any new fields, the annual decline would be about 14 percent a year. In the Lords, the minister said the OBR would “have to republish the figures if Rosebank does not go ahead”. Denyer asked whether any indication that the government is relying on the tax “could be considered indirect pressure. Could that risk making the decision unlawful?” The Conservative front bench asked whether the OBR had been given assurances that the field would be permitted. The minister’s answer, in the Lords, was a corrective the room did not repeat: “The OBR does not actually make forecasts. It recognises the potential tax receipts for Rosebank, but it does not actually give pounds and pence forecasts for it.”

So there are four numbers for one field, and the decider has endorsed none of them. The Conservative front bench puts Rosebank at around half a billion pounds a year in direct tax revenues, and tens of billions of gross added value. Lord Moynihan, in the Lords, put the lifetime tax take at “north of £10 billion” at today’s oil prices, and spoke of “over 1,000 Scottish workers and their families”. Adura’s own figures, carried by the Scottish Sun, are £1.4 billion in tax by 2029 and £3.8 billion by 2034. Against all three stands Fahnbulleh’s own document, in which she says she could not form a view on tax receipts “in which she has sufficient confidence”. Even with Rosebank approved, the OBR expects the sector’s receipts to fall to close to zero by 2031-32.

The public, unlike the cabinet, gets to write to the file. The regulator’s July 2026 public notice on the further information for both fields drew published representations, and they read very differently from the debate. Uplift, the research group, calculates 255 jobs over the oilfield’s lifetime. DNV, the energy consultancy, submitted that without further recovery from fields such as Jackdaw and Rosebank, the proportion of imported hydrocarbons would rise “from about 50% today to close to 100% by 2050”. One respondent, logged as R1255, wrote: “There’s not many jobs in Rosebank. Uplift say it’ll be 255 jobs over the oilfield’s lifetime. As the North Sea is a mature basin now, jobs are going to keep falling away, as they have since the late 90’s.” The representations are part of the evidence the Secretary of State must read. They are published, redacted, on GOV.UK.

The people arguing about Rosebank outside the file speak the file’s own language, and mostly argue about the things it weighs least. Jet McDonald, writing on Instagram to his MP and to the prime minister, inverted the four official claims one by one: “Rosebank won’t provide energy security. Rosebank won’t lower gas and energy bills. Rosebank won’t secure future jobs. Rosebank will release 250 million tonnes of CO2 over the next twenty five years.” Mark Collins, commenting on the Stop Cambo campaign’s Facebook post, made the case the other way: “We need to drill and supply our own rather than transport and import at higher costs and higher carbon impact. While the merit in stopping uk drilling is fine, the reality is we still need it and homegrown is actually better for the planet and uk households”. On X, a poster called Chambo answered an MP’s post against the field with the question the jobs figures never answer: “Will you pay my wages when i lose my job because of your bullshit???” The file’s answer to him is a number neither side quotes: 255 jobs over the field’s lifetime, against the developer’s case for approval. And the bills argument, the one most people make first, is the one the decision document gives negligible weight to, in writing.

Chris Brett, the chief executive of Altera Infrastructure, which owns the floating production vessel that would produce the field, put the industry’s case in a statement shared on Facebook on Friday. “I have been working in the North Sea for more than 35 years and offshore for more than 40 years,” he wrote. “It is not just a job, it is a way of life.” He visited the Petrojarl Rosebank at the Drydock World yard in Dubai last month, and called her “a symbol of how much the UK has to lose if it does not approve Rosebank”. The vessel left Dubai in late February and arrived on location in June, and has been on station since.

On Friday, the Stop Rosebank day of action put protesters outside MPs’ offices from Aberdeen to Exeter. About 30 people gathered at Patricia Ferguson’s Glasgow surgery, at Partick Library. Ferguson told the Glasgow Times: “I have not signed the Rosebank pledge, but I am against the idea of developing the Rosebank field.” Parents and children chalked “Stop Rosebank” on the pavement outside Ellie Reeves’s office in Dulwich. Sixty-nine MPs and 15 MSPs have signed the Stop Rosebank pledge. Rosie, a protester in Edinburgh, wrote on Instagram on Friday: “I refuse to give up on my children’s future.” She had spent the day with the North Sea Knitters, the group that organised the action. “We can stop Rosebank. We need to keep up this pressure. We need to keep being loud. We need to keep taking action.”

The same government, in the same month, decided a very similar question on a different desk. The foreign secretary, Ed Miliband, signed off the Falklands’ Sea Lion field on 13 October, the same day Argentina asked the tribunal in Hamburg to halt it. Sea Lion holds an estimated 1.7 billion barrels, 500 million of them recoverable. The project costs £1.55 billion. First oil is expected in March 2028. The Falkland Islands Government had already approved it, and under Falklands legislation new licences require the foreign secretary’s consent. That is a political signature. Rosebank, at 300 million barrels, waits on a desk where politics is not allowed to count. The Conservative front bench asked the question in Wednesday’s debate that no one in the field has picked up: why has one been allowed while the other is still stuck in limbo?

One peer, in the Lords, put a question the minister declined to answer. Rosebank sits at a depth of more than a kilometre, the deepest development ever proposed on the UK continental shelf, and a major oil spill could have serious impact on at least 16 UK marine protected areas. The minister said she would not be drawn into any detail about the decision, and that the Secretary of State would be given a range of information she would read and study carefully, and would make the decision in the round.