News

The Fourth Branch of 911 Is Spreading Across the U.S.

Unarmed responders are reshaping how cities handle 911 calls

The traditional structure of emergency response in the United States is undergoing its most significant evolution since the creation of the national 911 system in 1968. For more than half a century, municipal emergency dispatch has relied on police, fire, and emergency medical services. A growing national movement is now establishing a “fourth branch” of public safety: unarmed community response teams for non-violent, socio-economic, and behavioral health crises.

The movement accelerated after the 2020 police killing of George Floyd in Minneapolis and the nationwide demands for criminal justice reform that followed. In 2020, only six municipal programs dispatched unarmed clinicians or peer specialists to 911 calls instead of police. Today, nearly 100 cities have such programs.

Durham, North Carolina, has become a national model. Since launching its Holistic Empathetic Assistance Response Team, or HEART, in 2022, the city’s program has processed more than 25,000 calls. Durham officials are also pursuing a shift from immediate crisis de-escalation toward chronic poverty and homelessness, the systemic issues that generate emergency calls.

A 2023 preliminary study by Duke University researchers found that HEART’s introduction was associated with an increase in overall 911 call volume. Researchers identified that increase as a marker of growing public trust in municipal emergency services.

In Denver, the Support Team Assisted Response (STAR) program launched in 2020. A 2022 Stanford University study found that alternative dispatch reduced reports of minor, non-violent offenses by more than 34% in its target areas. Eugene, Oregon, is home to CAHOOTS (Crisis Assistance Helping Out On The Streets), the nation’s oldest alternative response program, founded in 1989. A 2025 study there found that unarmed dispatch significantly lowered the likelihood of arrests while streamlining patient access to preventative medical care.

Durham’s results also include a subsequent 2024 study by the Research Triangle Institute (RTI), which linked the program to a reduction in arrests, high satisfaction among traditional police officers, and an extremely low rate of teams requiring armed backup.

Alternative response programs have faced serious operational and structural hurdles. In New York City, the 2024 shooting of Win Rozario, a teenager experiencing a mental health crisis, exposed critical gaps in the city’s pilot program. A 2025 audit by the Office of the New York City Comptroller confirmed that the vast majority of municipal neighborhoods remained entirely outside its service area.

Baltimore encountered a different problem after the 2025 police shooting of Pytorcarcha Brooks during a mental health crisis. An investigation by The Baltimore Sun found that the city’s alternative dispatch volume had dropped by more than 50% in recent years even as emergency psychiatric calls increased. Baltimore officials are now evaluating Durham’s model as a blueprint for reform.

Per-capita utilization is one key measure of alternative dispatch systems. Amos Irwin, a researcher at the Law Enforcement Action Partnership (LEAP), said Durham’s HEART program handles approximately 28 calls per 1,000 residents, placing it among the ten most active programs nationwide.

Irwin said many municipal programs plateau because of restrictive dispatch criteria or chronic underfunding. Many agencies permit alternative dispatch only for explicit psychiatric crises, although the vast majority of calls suitable for unarmed intervention present as low-level quality-of-life complaints.

Before HEART launched, Durham’s Community Safety Department partnered with RTI to analyze three years of historical 911 data. The review identified low-risk call types that rarely involved violence, including trespassing, public intoxication, panhandling, indecency, and welfare checks.

Leigh Mazur, assistant director of the Durham Community Safety Department, explained that without rigid dispatch protocols, 911 operators will naturally err on the side of caution and send armed officers to scenes where they are not structurally required.

Former Durham Police Chief Patrice Andrews helped launch HEART before leaving the force. She said officers initially had deep anxieties about the physical safety of unarmed responders, as well as political concerns that the program represented a lack of support for police.

Durham addressed those tensions by integrating HEART responders directly into the primary municipal emergency radio network. Police officers and unarmed responders could then monitor one another in real time, changing law enforcement’s perception of the program from an external political initiative to a functional extension of the public safety net.

Peer support specialist Rob Crisp and mental health clinician Allie Craft are among the teams working under this system. Crisp, who has personal experience overcoming substance abuse, uses relationship-building and shared experience to de-escalate volatile encounters.

During a response to a business property, an individual with multiple belongings refused to leave. Crisp and Craft provided water, dry socks, and basic supplies, then negotiated a peaceful relocation to a nearby vacant lot without law enforcement intervention.

Immediate de-escalation can leave responders facing problems that cannot be resolved during a single call. In a domestic dispute involving a mother and her adult daughter, Brittney, the HEART team confronted a complex housing crisis. Brittney declined when responders explained that the only immediate housing option was a local homeless shelter.

Mariela Ruiz-Angel, director of community safety initiatives at Georgetown Law’s Center for Innovations in Community Safety and founder of Albuquerque’s community response program, said alternative response was originally designed to prevent police violence, not to solve systemic homelessness or poverty.

Ruiz-Angel said municipal programs nationwide face a strategic crossroad: remain focused exclusively on short-term crisis management or attempt to resolve the structural deficits that drive emergency calls.

Durham Community Safety Department director Ryan Smith emphasizes that replacing an officer with a social worker is only the first step. The city established a specialized division called Stabilization Services to address the root causes of emergency calls.

Led by Anise Vance, Stabilization Services follows up after the immediate emergency has passed and connects individuals with long-term housing, medical services, behavioral healthcare, and food security.

The division’s long-term goal is to build a preventative safety net so that fewer vulnerable residents find themselves in a state of crisis requiring a 911 response in the first place.