
Savannah Guthrie posted her daughter’s drawing on November 1. Vale, 12, had drawn an umbrella under rain and written underneath it: “I know it might not seem like it but I really need my Mommy.” Her mother added the words the family has been saying for nine months. “The world goes on, things appear ‘normal’ — as we try to keep going and be strong, especially for our young kids — but it’s not and it never will be,” she wrote. “We are begging you. Please help us.”
That post is the family’s most recent public message about the case. The sheriff’s last word is older. On October 30, Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos issued a statement about DNA analysis and a trip to Florida. It ran four sentences. Twenty-three days have passed since, and no official update has followed. February 1 is 71 days away — one year since she was reported missing.
On January 31, Nancy Guthrie’s son-in-law dropped her at her Catalina Foothills home after dinner, at 9:48 p.m. The garage door closed at 9:50. After 1:47 a.m. the doorbell camera went dark, and at 2:12 a.m. a person was detected at the house. Her pacemaker, which she depended on for a heart condition, last synced at about 2:30 a.m. Blood on the front porch was Nancy’s. The family called 911 at 12:03 p.m., after she did not show up for church.

Sheriff Nanos held three news briefings in the days after the disappearance and has not held one since. On February 10 the FBI released the doorbell video: a masked person, a backpack, what looked like a gun holster, covering the camera with branches. A man questioned after a traffic stop in Rio Rico that week was released and is not a suspect. On February 12 the FBI raised its reward from $50,000 to $100,000 and described the man as about 5 feet 9 to 5 feet 10, average build, carrying a black 25-litre Ozark Trail Hiker Pack. On February 16 the sheriff cleared the family. “Not one single person in the family is a suspect,” Nanos said.
A glove found about two miles from the house, on the 17th day, carried DNA that matched nothing in the national database; CBS later reported the gloves were traced to a restaurant worker with no connection to the case. DNA found on the property two weeks in has never been identified. A mixed sample from inside the home gave only a partial profile, too thin for the database and too thin for genetic genealogy. Hair found in the home had no DNA on it at all, the FBI said on July 30. When the Tucson reporter Briana Whitney asked about the DNA evidence a few days after the disappearance, Nanos texted back, “Did you happen to notice the time? Give it a rest,” she said on a podcast in July.
Two ransom notes arrived in the first days, and they contradict each other. The first demanded $4 million in cryptocurrency, according to the Economic Times. The second, sent on February 6, said she “perished shortly after she was taken” and was buried “in nature now.” The family replied to the notes and never heard back, CBS reported. In July the sheriff published two of the notes, hoping someone would recognise the writer’s style. No one has. A text message that surfaced in late September was checked and ruled not credible, and a California man was charged early on with sending a hoax ransom message.
On October 30 the sheriff broke the silence with four sentences. “The Nancy Guthrie Task Force continues to work with our labs in hopes of furthering our DNA analysis in this investigation,” Nanos said. “Earlier this month, investigators traveled to Florida to meet with lab scientists to see what more could be done to advance the case.” “A number of ideas were discussed, and we continue to work with all of our partners to solve this case,” he said. “We want to remind the public that no tip is too small. Even the smallest piece of information could be critical to this investigation.” The statement named no lab, described no idea and released no result. Nanos has since said the evidence is spread across laboratories in Florida, Kansas, San Francisco, Washington and Phoenix.
On November 9, retired homicide detective Chris McDonough told NewsNation the DNA work would not solve the case and investigators should focus on interviews. On November 16, retired FBI agent Maureen O’Connell told Brian Entin’s podcast that the family’s request for friends not to talk was “beyond strange.” O’Connell also went back to the first night, questioning the two minutes between the 9:48 p.m. drop-off and the garage door closing at 9:50, and asking how Nancy, who had difficulty walking, could have made it inside that fast. Neither of them is on the task force, and neither has seen the evidence file. The department has issued no new statement since October 30.
Between November 14 and 17, at least eleven websites republished old stories as new: a February DUI arrest outside the house, the February questioning in Rio Rico, a June arrest and a Mexico grave-site tip. One headline this week announced that Nancy Guthrie “has been found.” The story underneath it says she has not. A reader who trusts the date at the top of the page would believe something happened. A March story about the search entering its seventh week ran with a November 17 date.
On November 6, a Threads user named Charles Ziegler told his followers the case had “shifted gears” and “Arrest are imminent!” Amazing, he wrote, how a little “Leather band” changed the whole perspective of the case. No arrest has been announced, and no leather band appears in any official statement. His own readers caught it first, and their replies are the check the outlets did not run. “They deserve to know. Please don’t fool the family nor us,” wrote @lgap50. “Fake news,” wrote @hall_fran. “Not nice. The family’s going through a lot. Please try to have empathy for them,” wrote @stephanie.slagle. “Pray they solve her disappearance soon,” wrote @dampiermartha.
On Thursday, Savannah Guthrie will co-host the 100th Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade with Hoda Kotb and Al Roker, as NBC announced on November 19. Her mother has been missing for 294 days.
The reward still stands at about $1.2 million — $1 million from the family, $100,000 from the FBI and $102,500 from 88-CRIME. The FBI had received more than 13,000 tips by February. Anyone with information is asked to call 1-800-CALL-FBI or the local anonymous line, 520-88-CRIME.





