Sports

United Sacked Michael Carrick After 10 Games. He Won 12 of the 17 Before Them.

United's 142-word statement praises the 17-game run in the same breath that ends it. The fixtures say the ten games that followed were the easier test.

Manchester United‘s statement sacking Michael Carrick runs to 142 words. Its second paragraph says he “guided the team to a third-placed Premier League finish by winning 12 out of the remaining 17 games of the 2025/26 season, accumulating the highest points tally in the league during that period.” Its third paragraph says the club “has come to the extremely difficult conclusion that a change is necessary in order to achieve our ambitions.”

On 22 May, the club announced that Carrick would continue as head coach on a contract running to 2028, having won 11 of 16 games to that point. Jason Wilcox, the director of football, said Carrick had “thoroughly earned the opportunity” and praised “the winning culture at Carrington and in the dressing room, which we are continuing to build.” The seventeenth game, a 3-0 win at Brighton, came two days later. The Times reported that Wilcox and chief executive Omar Berrada decided on Monday that Carrick’s position was untenable, then flew to Monaco on Wednesday to put it to Sir Jim Ratcliffe.

United took 39 points from the seventeen games: twelve wins, three draws, two defeats, 33 scored and 18 conceded. They took eight points from the ten: one win, five draws, four defeats, 14 scored and 19 conceded. The points rate fell from 2.29 a game to 0.8, and the goals conceded nearly doubled, from 1.06 a game to 1.9.

In the seventeen, United faced five sides sitting in the top six at the time, Arsenal, Manchester City, Liverpool, Aston Villa and Chelsea, and beat all five. In the ten, they faced two, City and Chelsea, and lost both. By the opponents’ league positions at the time, the autumn run was the marginally easier of the two. The spring defeats came at Newcastle and Leeds. The autumn defeats came at Hull, Bournemouth, City and Chelsea, and the only win came against Ipswich.

Casemiro scored five of the spring’s league goals before he was released on 30 June. André Onana was loaned to Trabzonspor on 3 July. Senne Lammens played all ten autumn league games. He conceded 19 goals in them. The £150 million midfield rebuild brought Carlos Baleba for £70 million from Brighton, and Baleba has started three league games. Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans arrived too. No defender arrived, and Luke Shaw is still the only established senior left-back in the squad.

The defence has been disorganised all autumn, and United sit 18th, in the relegation zone. United twice trailed by two goals in the 4-4 draw with Aston Villa on Sunday, and Reuters counted the decision to leave captain Bruno Fernandes on the bench for the 3-0 defeat by Bournemouth among the marks against him. The nine-match winless run across all competitions, from 13 September to 31 October, was the club’s first since 1988-89.

On Reddit, under the club’s statement, the supporters argued about the summer. “Our bad for not signing a full back or back up striker,” wrote Fightingdragonswithu. MrSam52 wrote: “What ambitions? Sorry but 2 promoted teams spent more than us, all three spent more on net terms, regardless of anything else, if you sack a manager after 12 games having given him absolutely nothing in the summer then a large portion of the responsibility is on the club, this is absolute shambles, how are we in a worse state now than when the Glazers had sole control?”

A third supporter, a_guy_called_m, wrote: “sucks that things have to end this way :/ carrick has probably bought me the most joy post-fergie since ole’s first few months. I hope he gets a chance somewhere that deserves him.”

CNN says Mauricio Pochettino has reached a verbal agreement with the club, and The Times puts the compensation to US Soccer at about £7.5 million. CNN also says he is expected to stay in charge of the United States for its next two matches before any move, and talks continue this week. The club’s statement names no successor and no interim, and United’s next game is at Liverpool on 22 November.

As permanent head coach, Carrick lasted 174 days, the shortest of any United manager since Ferguson retired in 2013. He first took charge as interim on 13 January. Ruben Amorim had departed days earlier.