News

Thomas Jefferson’s DNA Resolves the Hemings Paternity Dispute

A historic lock of hair provides the strongest genetic evidence linking Thomas Jefferson to Sally Hemings’ descendants.

The relationship between Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings entered the public record in 1802, when political journalist James T. Callender alleged in the Richmond Recorder that Jefferson had fathered children with an enslaved woman named Sally. Jefferson, who wrote that “all men are created equal” while owning more than 600 enslaved people over his lifetime, never publicly addressed the allegations.

More than two centuries later, researchers have mapped Jefferson’s genome using advanced paleogenomic techniques. DNA extracted from a historic lock of hair has provided the most definitive genetic evidence to date that the third U.S. president fathered Hemings’ children at his Monticello estate.

Sally Hemings was the half-sister of Jefferson’s late wife, Martha Wayles Skelton Jefferson; both were daughters of John Wayles. Hemings came to Monticello as part of Martha’s inheritance. In 1787, she accompanied Jefferson’s young daughter, Maria, to Paris while Jefferson served as the U.S. Minister to France.

Although French law gave Hemings a path to petition for freedom, she returned to Virginia with Jefferson in 1789. Her descendants said she agreed to return only after Jefferson promised that her children would be freed when they reached adulthood.

The new project was spearheaded by Richard Kurin, a distinguished scholar and ambassador-at-large for the Smithsonian Institution, after a 15-year investigation. Its methodology, scientific challenges, and historical implications are detailed in Kurin’s book, History by a Hair.

Before Kurin’s study, the most important scientific effort to address the paternity question came in 1998. Pathologist Eugene Foster led a team that analyzed the Y chromosome of male-line descendants of Field Jefferson, Thomas Jefferson’s uncle, because the president had no surviving legitimate sons to pass on his Y chromosome. The researchers compared those results with male-line descendants of Eston Hemings, Sally’s youngest son.

Published in Nature, the 1998 study found a perfect Y-chromosome match. Most historians regarded the result as evidence that Jefferson was Eston Hemings’ father. Defenders of Jefferson’s traditional legacy, including members of the Thomas Jefferson Heritage Society, said the finding was circumstantial.

Because the Y chromosome passes from father to son with little change, those defenders argued that the match could have belonged to any male in the Jefferson line who was present at Monticello. They cited Thomas Jefferson’s younger brother, Randolph Jefferson, or one of Randolph’s sons as possible alternatives.

Kurin collaborated with Beth Shapiro, a MacArthur fellow and expert in ancient DNA from extinct species, and Richard “Ed” Green, a pioneer in paleogenomics and forensic genomics. Both researchers are at the University of California, Santa Cruz. Their aim was to generate empirical scientific data about the lineage independently of the long-running moral and historical debates surrounding Jefferson’s legacy.

The search for Jefferson’s personal DNA source lasted more than a decade. The team initially examined strands of hair kept inside Jefferson’s personal Bible, but five years of testing established that the strands did not belong to the former president.

The breakthrough came when Kurin revisited the collections of the Thomas Jefferson Foundation at Monticello. He found an uninventoried packet containing a well-preserved lock of hair labeled as having been cut from Jefferson’s head on July 4, 1826—the day Jefferson died and the 50th anniversary of the adoption of the Declaration of Independence.

Historical hair shafts generally lack the roots that contain nuclear DNA, making DNA extraction exceptionally difficult. Shapiro and Green nevertheless used modern paleogenomic techniques to recover and sequence viable genomic DNA from the lock.

The researchers then compared Jefferson’s mapped genome with genetic material from known descendants of Madison and Eston Hemings. The genomic analysis produced a direct match. Some modern Hemings descendants possessed a higher concentration of Thomas Jefferson’s DNA than some recognized white descendants from his marriage to Martha Wayles.

The genetic analysis covered descendants of Madison and Eston Hemings, but Kurin’s team could not trace descendants of Sally Hemings’ other two surviving children, Harriet and Beverly Hemings. Historical records say Harriet and Beverly left Monticello in 1822 with Jefferson’s tacit consent, moved to Washington, D.C., and integrated into white society. Their lineages were subsequently lost to the historical record.

Madison and Eston Hemings remained at Monticello until Jefferson’s death in 1826. They were officially freed in his will.

Kurin’s team is preparing the findings for publication in a peer-reviewed scientific journal. After the peer-review process, the researchers plan to make Jefferson’s complete mapped genome publicly available, allowing members of the public to cross-reference their own DNA data and potentially discover previously undocumented genealogical connections to the third president.