Senator Elissa Slotkin asked the acting Navy secretary a plain question: a year ago, did a commercial ship need a military escort through the Strait of Hormuz or the Bab el-Mandeb? Hung Cao did not answer it. He answered with insurance instead. A transit cost $54,000 a year ago, he said, and $64 million now. Slotkin told him he was dodging the question.
War-risk cover is priced as a percentage of a ship’s hull value. The Hormuz insurance $64 million figure is therefore a claim about a percentage, and percentages can be checked. The market publishes its rates, and brokers publish hull values, so the hearing’s number can be tested against both.
Clarksons Research put a five-year-old VLCC at $220 million on November 16, up from $120 million at the end of last year. At the 7 to 9 percent war-risk rates Insurance Business reported on November 9, insuring that ship for one Hormuz transit costs $15.4 million to $19.8 million. Cao’s $64 million is 29 percent of the hull. Even the most expensive VLCC afloat, a prompt resale valued at $245 million, costs $24.5 million to insure at the highest rate anyone has reported for the Gulf, 10 percent. Add the cargo, two million barrels at about $92, and the insured value reaches roughly $404 million. Ten percent of that is $40.4 million. S&P Global’s July estimate, $21 million for a laden 270,000-tonne tanker, sits inside the same band.
Fifty-four thousand dollars to $64 million is a 1,185-fold increase. The market’s own increase is 28 to 40 times: Marsh puts the pre-war rate at about 0.25 percent of hull value and the current rate at 7 to 9 percent, while a VLCC transit that cost about $250,000 before the war has been quoted above $10 million. Cao’s multiple is roughly thirty times the market’s. His starting figure does not fit either. At the 0.25 percent pre-war rate, $54,000 buys cover for a $21.6 million hull, and no tanker is worth that little. It fits a rate near 0.05 percent on a $108 million ship, which is what the Howden Re data suggests the pre-war additional premium was. The market cannot agree with itself on the pre-war baseline by a factor of five, but every version of the present agrees: the price is $10 million to $21 million, not $64 million.
Asked by Senator Elizabeth Warren what the naval blockade of Iranian ports costs each day, Cao said, “Senator, I do not know the daily cost, ma’am.” Warren put the figure at about $32.5 million a day, as high as $42 million, and asked if that sounded right. Cao replied, “Senator, let me do some quick Asian math in my head, but yes, it’s about $30 billion so far.” The war began on February 28. By November 17 it had run 262 days. At $32.5 million a day the blockade costs $8.5 billion; at $42 million a day, $11 billion. Thirty billion dollars would need about $114 million a day, nearly three times the highest estimate Warren cited. The Pentagon’s own estimate for the whole war passed $47 billion in October.
Cao also told Warren the Navy had “already protected 3700 ships.” The Joint Maritime Information Center counted 83 US-facilitated transits in the 72 hours to November 14, about 28 a day. At that rate 3,700 ships is roughly 132 days of escorting, in the right order of magnitude for an operation running since the spring. The money figures are the outliers. So is the rate Cao’s figure implies. The Black Sea, where Lloyd’s List reports hull war premiums up to 20 percent, is the most expensive war-risk market of 2026, with more than 570 ships attacked and 40 sailors killed. Twenty-nine percent would price the Gulf above it.
Before the war, Gulf war-risk cover cost 0.15 to 0.25 percent of hull value. It spiked to 10 percent in the days after the February 28 strikes, ran at 7.5 to 10 percent in July, and was quoted at 6 to 10 percent in mid-October. By November 9 it had eased to 7 to 9 percent, with some cover written at 5 percent. The easing came while the attacks continued. More than 110 claims have piled up, with estimated payouts around $2.5 billion, and Marsh Re puts Middle East war, terrorism and political-violence losses above $2 billion against about $2.5 billion in annual gross premiums for the class. New capacity entered the market and chased the business down, not better security.
On Reddit’s r/maritime in September, a seafarer writing as u/zorasa61 wrote that his crew manager had asked whether he was willing to go to the Strait of Hormuz, “only for knowledge purpose,” and wondered whether saying no meant the company would “prefer someone said ‘yes’.” Another, u/dragon_soup_, told him to ask for triple pay: “Ask for triple pay. A lot of the guys stuck are on triple or more. Do t be scared to say no, they’re desperate for people as everyone else is refusing.” A third, u/dENd0Mania, put his own danger pay at “$10 for each day while in Hormuz area.” The reply underneath, from u/JimBones31, was two words: “Holy shit that’s low.”
The published rates for officers run higher. Tanker captains are being offered the equivalent of $100,000 a month plus $50,000 per crossing, according to the Financial Times, while ordinary crew get four to six times their normal pay. The International Maritime Organization’s secretary-general, Arsenio Dominguez, has said of the strait: “It is just not safe to go through the Strait of Hormuz.” The hearing never mentioned the crews. Cao’s $64 million prices the ship and its cargo; the people on board price the same transit in tens of dollars a day, and no figure in the hearing covers that gap. A third officer, Ashutosh Shikhare, filming himself on the bridge at night posted a reel from his ship this month with the caption “My ship going to straits of hormuz #warzone #straitofhormuz #MERCHANTNAVY.”
Suezmaxes and Aframaxes moved more than a million barrels a day through the strait in October, a wartime high, according to Vortexa, and total exports reached 10.3 million barrels a day, the highest since the conflict began. The Lucia A, a Suezmax, has picked up at least four Iraqi cargoes since June and loaded a fifth this month. Another, the Ture, collected its third last week. A Suezmax run from the Gulf to China costs roughly a third to just under half the VLCC benchmark rate. That is also why two measures of the strait disagree: Reuters’ oil reporting says crude shipments have returned to roughly pre-war levels, while the UK Maritime Trade Operations counts vessel crossings about 65 percent below pre-war. The cargo moved to smaller hulls, and the count of hulls fell with it.
France is in talks with Saudi Arabia and other Gulf states about a state-backed vehicle to take on part of the insurance risk for Hormuz transits, Bloomberg reported on November 10. The precedent is discouraging. A $40 billion American guarantee set up for the same purpose had not written a single policy as of May 17.
Brent crude traded around $92 a barrel on Thursday, down 1.3 percent the previous session. VLCC spot earnings averaged $304,482 a day last week, down 41 percent in a week, after touching $1.3 million a day in October. The Joint Maritime Information Center still rates the threat in the strait severe, with deliberate attack highly likely, and counts 183 confirmed incidents since March 1.





