Keyshawn Johnson was telling a story about a phone call on a podcast this week, and he got to the part where Deion Sanders rang him after Shedeur complained. “I want to see him start, Shedeur, because the last time I said something about him on TV, he went and told his daddy. And then Prime had to call me and tell me to cuss his a** out.” Johnson was on All The Smoke Unplugged with Matt Barnes, arguing that Shedeur should start for the Cleveland Browns, when he told it. He had seen Shedeur just minutes before the call, he said, and the quarterback was “acting weird.”
What Johnson said on television was praise. The Shedeur Sanders Keyshawn Johnson story starts there. Back in 2025, after Shedeur fell to the fifth round of the draft, Johnson said on FS1’s Speak that he viewed him as the best quarterback on the Browns. “He’s going to be, in my opinion, one of the most popular athlete in the state this season.” Shedeur heard something else. “He thought I was saying something negative about him when I was the only one in all the media saying something positive about him. But he didn’t know. He just lumped y’all in.” By Johnson’s account, Shedeur lumped him in with all Black journalists. Johnson told him he had the wrong guy, and Deion was mad at his son because “he’s just a kid.”
A quarterback who has spent eighteen months being told the world is against him does not hear a compliment the way it was meant. Shedeur went into the 2025 draft projected by some as the No. 1 pick. The night before the first round, CBS’s Jonathan Jones said on the air that there was “a very good chance” he would not be selected on Thursday night. He was not. He fell out of the first round, then the second and third, and the Browns finally took him 144th overall on the third day, in the fifth round. President Donald Trump weighed in on Truth Social, asking what was wrong with NFL owners. The conversation around the slide descended into racial debates, with ESPN’s Stephen A. Smith comparing the situation to Colin Kaepernick’s exile from the league. Smith later told Chris Rock, according to Rock’s brother Tony, that the slide had a different cause: coaches did not want to draft a quarterback whose father could replace them. The team that finally picked him said the father had nothing to do with it. Browns general manager Andrew Berry said Deion “was not a significant factor for us.”
On Monday, three days before Johnson retold the story, Hall of Fame receiver Cris Carter said on his “Fully Loaded” podcast that Shedeur’s camp had “overplayed their hand” before the draft, trying to direct where he would land, skipping the combine, “acting like he was in the same situation as Eli Manning.” Carter estimated the slide cost Shedeur $30 million to $50 million in earnings and endorsements. Deion answered in the podcast’s Instagram comments. “That never happened. All you got to do is ask for the truth, my brother. The story you told about Shedeur in the car at the Super Bowl is who he is. How does that add up when the draft hadn’t taken place at that time? God bless you, though.” The deal Shedeur actually signed was four years and $4.65 million, and on Carter’s own estimate the slide cost him six to eleven times that whole contract.
Shedeur got his chance because Deshaun Watson got hurt. Watson took a helmet-to-helmet hit from safety Jaquan Brisker in the Browns’ 27-6 loss to Pittsburgh on November 1. Shedeur filled in for four plays and completed both of his passes for two yards. Watson cleared the protocol and returned to the game that day, then symptoms surfaced the following night and sent him into the protocol. Coach Todd Monken named Shedeur the starter on November 6. In New Orleans two days later, Shedeur threw for 38 yards before halftime. Then he produced 177 yards and two touchdowns in the final 5:21 of regulation and overtime: a 64-yard touchdown to rookie KC Concepcion that gave Cleveland a 13-9 lead, a drive capped by a game-tying field goal, and a 39-yard touchdown to Harold Fannin Jr. in overtime that pulled the Browns within a point. The two-point try to Denzel Boston fell incomplete, and Cleveland lost 23-22. The line was 19 of 31 for 297 yards and two touchdowns, no interceptions, a 114.6 passer rating. FanSided printed 114.9; the Beacon Journal printed 114.4. The line itself computes to 114.6. Monken noticed what it took. “I thought for 10 weeks of really not taking any reps, I thought he did a really good job.”
Three days later Monken gave the job back to Watson. “Ultimately, the full body of work, the previous eight games that we had played, Deshaun played pretty well,” he said on Wednesday. “He played well enough to earn to still be our starter.” He added that he had no intention of Watson not being the starter, and that he did not know why he had to say it publicly. Watson, asked the same day whether he had worried about losing the job, said he had not. “You’d have to ask Monk about that. My job is to just come in every day, [do] whatever is required for the day.” The game logs make Monken’s case and Shedeur’s at the same time. Watson’s eight starts: 163 of 249 for 1,806 yards, seven touchdowns, three interceptions, a 91.2 rating, 5-3 as a starter, with five game-winning drives in the fourth quarter of the five wins. Shedeur’s one start beat Watson’s rating in seven of those eight games, the only exception Tampa Bay’s 121.9. His 9.6 yards per attempt beat every Watson start, whose best was 9.3. His 297 yards were beaten only twice, 308 at Tennessee and 324 at Pittsburgh. Watson’s case is the record and the drives. Shedeur’s case is that his one afternoon included a comeback of the same kind, and it ended on a two-point conversion that did not work.
Deion watched the week from Colorado and talked about what it has done to his son. “He’s matured so much, and he’s grown so much in the last year or so that I’m really, really proud of it because he’s never had to deal with circumstances,” he said on Wednesday. “We’ve always dealt with chatter. If your last name is Sanders, you’re going to deal with chatter. We’ve always dealt with that from youth all the way up. But the level of dysfunction that permeates around is crazy.” A day later he went further. “When he takes off his shirt, I see the scars on his back that he’s been through hell, but he’s made it through hell. He kept going and he matured, not like he was a child, but he matured spiritually.” Darius Slay spoke up two days later. The Super Bowl champion cornerback publicly urged the Minnesota Vikings to trade for Shedeur.
On Threads, blackassterry wrote in all caps that “SHEDEUR SANDERS SHOULD NOT BE NOBODY’S BACKUP QUARTERBACK. I’M STANDING ON THAT.” hotshot_0570 answered that anyone who thinks Shedeur is a starting quarterback in the NFL is “incredibly delusional.” macallister.heather said the start was an accident of the concussion: “Deshaun is concussed that is the only reason shedeur is playing.” The Watson side made the same case Monken did, with the numbers slightly wrong. topone.gbs backed Watson, “bra been balling,” and put the record at 6-2. It was 5-3. montreyw318 backed him on the drives, “he has 4game winning Drives so no reason to replace Watson.” The number is five. pablo.raccs put the condition on the game coming up: “Deshaun gets his last shot vs his ex team lol if he fails to win fails to score Sheduer will start for the rest of the year ?!!” His other charge checks out. Watson has not thrown a touchdown pass since October 11, against the Jets. None of the six mentioned the phone call. The story the media told all week is not the argument the fans are having.
Sanders has attempted 34 passes this season. Thirty-one of them came in one afternoon in New Orleans.





