Sports

Usman Khawaja Sandpaper Claims Point at a Coach the Denial Never Mentioned

Cummins denied being an 'architect' of a scheme. Khawaja's charge was collective knowledge — and the memoir's most specific passage points at the bowling coach, not the bowlers.

The most quoted sentence of Pat Cummins’s 68-minute press conference answers a charge Usman Khawaja never made. The Australian captain spent over an hour in Sydney on Friday denying that he and others were “architects of a scheme to ball tamper with sandpaper”. He called that “complete and utter nonsense”. Khawaja’s accusation is something else entirely. The team knew. Its sharpest passage describes a coach at lunch on the third day in Cape Town.

Khawaja’s line, given to the Sydney Morning Herald before Sabr was published on 11 November, is the one everyone can repeat: “It was all of us. Not the batters, not the bowlers, not the staff. All of us.” The Usman Khawaja sandpaper claims, as the book sets them out, are about knowledge shared across a dressing room, not a plan drawn up by anyone in particular. Cummins answered a different sentence. “When he says we all knew, if by that he means that we knew sandpaper was going out in the field, he’s 100 per cent wrong,” he said, and then he raised the stakes himself: “He says that I and others were architects of a scheme to ball tamper with sandpaper.” Warner, the one man banned for leading the plot, has backed Khawaja as “100 per cent accurate” and called the investigation “rushed and botched”. On Instagram he added that Cricket Australia did not interview Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc or Nathan Lyon. Starc answered that the bowlers were “heavily grilled through the process, at the time and since”.

“I was genuinely shocked this week when I found out that Usman admitted that he told Cam to be careful when using sandpaper,” Cummins said. Khawaja’s book says he knew sandpaper was going out onto the field in Cape Town, and his response in the moment was a warning to the man carrying it, not a stop. Cummins called that “not the Usman that I know”, and said the Usman he knows “would have stopped that from happening there and then”. Khawaja has refused to name any individual bowler in the days since, and Mitchell Johnson, writing in The West Australian, said that refusal “raises more questions” — the book’s author will say the room knew, and will not say who in it designed anything.

The coach in the book is never named. The Sydney Morning Herald identified him on Thursday as David Saker, the bowling coach on the 2018 tour. Khawaja writes that the coach told Bancroft, “Bangers, whatever you’re doing, we need more of it. It’s wet out there — we just need more of it,” and then watched Bancroft put a piece of sandpaper in his pocket and “gave both me and Cameron a wry smile of satisfaction and walked away”. Before the series, at a team meeting, the same coach had told the bowlers, “We need to get the ball shifting when it gets old. I don’t care what you have to do, or how, but we need to get it moving in the air.”

The Herald also reported, from tour sources, that Saker told Smith and Bancroft before their press conference that day, repeatedly, “You can’t say sandpaper.” Bancroft told reporters the object was tape. It was sandpaper. The word was not admitted publicly until Cricket Australia announced its sanctions. Saker signed a non-disclosure agreement with Cricket Australia when he left the organisation in February 2019. He has not answered the Herald’s identification in public. The nearest thing to a position from him is five years old, a column he wrote for the same newspaper in May 2021: “There were a lot of people to blame. It could have been me to blame, it could have been someone else. It could have been stopped and it wasn’t, which is unfortunate.”

Khawaja’s book is, among other things, a record of two attempts to say all of this in public, and two men talking him out of it. In 2018 he went to Smith, who “talked me out of it”, because, Khawaja writes, Smith “wanted to take the blame”. Later he found the coach Darren Lehmann by a pool and told him he was going to come clean, that the team should cop it together. Lehmann told him the punishments had already been handed down and coming out now would only make things worse, and Khawaja writes that he gave in “because at the end of the day this is what the team had decided”. In 2021 he tried again. Bancroft had told the Guardian it was “self-explanatory” that the bowlers must have known, so Khawaja went to the coach Justin Langer and to Todd Greenberg, then the players’ association chief, to argue for collective responsibility. Four days later the four bowlers put out their joint statement, and the idea died. Cummins said on Friday that he had no recollection of Khawaja ever saying “Let’s all own this as a team”, and that he had spoken to “quite a few other people, and [they are] exactly the same”. Khawaja told Cummins and Greenberg what the book contained before it was published, and promised any leak during the series would not come from him.

Cummins called a second claim in the book the most serious thing he had read all week. Khawaja writes that he was passed over for the interim captaincy after the scandal because, in his words, “they weren’t ready for a brown Australian cricket captain”. Cummins said a claim like that needed evidence. He said he disagreed with it more than anything else in the book.

Khawaja dates the story earlier. Sandpaper was used a Test earlier. After tea on the second day at Port Elizabeth, with the umpires having left the ball on the boundary edge, Bancroft volunteered to use it at St George’s Park. And before South Africa there was the home Ashes of 2017-18, won 4-0, where the book says Australia lifted the quarter seam to get the ball reversing late on the fifth day. Cummins, asked about that, did not deny the seam. He said he now believed he had seen it happen and had taken it for normal deterioration at the time: “Maybe someone’s just tried to lift it up a tiny bit with a finger. I’ve not seen that since then. But at the time coming back into the team after not much cricket, I thought that was very normal.”

Todd Greenberg, Cricket Australia’s chief executive, told the radio station SEN that there was no compelling reason to reopen the investigation. In the same set of remarks he admitted the book contained “specific details… that contradict the versions that have been provided by others”. The organisation had previously said it would look at fresh information; Greenberg’s position is that it has looked, and its position has not changed. Michael Clarke, the former captain, wants the file reopened, and he put the stakes in terms of careers: “Steve Smith lost his job. If this doesn’t happen, Tim Paine never captains Australia. And neither does Cummins.” Cricket Australia’s chairman, David Boon, assured Cummins on Thursday that his job was safe. Cummins left the question of a new investigation to the board, and counted the silence in the room himself: eleven players, two accounts given, nine others whose stories, he said, deserve equal weight. Starc has repeated his 2021 denial. Bancroft has said nothing since the book came out. Mitchell Marsh, on the tour but not in the Cape Town side, declined to answer.

Ross Alman, commenting on the Sporting News Australia Facebook post that asked readers who they believed, made the same distinction in plainer language than any column has managed: “He only said he wasn’t aware of sandpaper being taken onto the ground. That leaves a lot out. He didn’t say he wasn’t aware of sandpaper being used on the ball, which would be the obvious statement if he was innocent.” Paul Ryan, on the same thread, wrote: “They all knew100% Or they must thought the team had nits scratching inside their pant all game!” Danny Cook took the other side: “I believe pat. Usman trying to sell more books.”

Mac Eliot asked the question Greenberg’s answer leaves open: “Did Khawaja make a statement at the time of the incident? CA should release it.” June Cerinich spoke for the other side of the argument, not for Cummins but for an end to it: “Khawaja has been dropped – is it revenge?? Nevertheless – time to move on!! It’s history!!” Clarke’s answer to that, on 2DayFM, was that Australian fans have not moved on, because they “can’t trust what’s real”.

The professionals who have weighed in have mostly asked the same question as the fans, from the other side of the ball. Wasim Akram, who made a career of reverse swing, said a bowler holding the ball would know the difference: “a sandpaper scratch is totally different from a one-bounce scratch”. He also hedged. In the same video he said “probably the team didn’t know at the time what was happening, in my opinion”. Johnson, in his column, said Khawaja had dodged the direct question about Cummins’s knowledge. He asked: “Anyone around the game wants answers. Don’t the fans deserve the truth?”

Chadd Sayers played one Test for Australia. It was the last of the 2018 series in Johannesburg. He told Fairfax newspapers this week that he believed what Khawaja wrote, and that, like Khawaja, he was never interviewed by Cricket Australia’s investigators.