Business

ATO Unpaid Super Recovery Raised $2.22 Billion but Returned Only $1.13 Billion

The Tax Office raised $2.22 billion in super guarantee charge last year and got $1.13 billion into workers' funds. The balance is still owed, mostly by 13,000 employers, and the workers waiting describe a slower system than the one the Tax Office announces.

Lockie has been waiting for his super since the end of 2022. The Tax Office has already issued a certificate saying his employer owes it.

“I am still waiting for my super to be paid since the end of 2022,” Lockie said in a video posted by Senator Fatima Payman on Instagram on 5 November. He had raised it with his fund, then with his employer. The employer promised the money would be paid, and then the Tax Office investigated and issued a super guarantee certificate. The employer had no money. He was willing to pay, Lockie said. On Thursday the Tax Office announced it had helped return more than $1.1 billion in unpaid super. The money reached more than 900,000 Australians in the past year. Its own snapshot for 2025–26, published the same day, puts the fuller ledger at $2.22 billion raised in super guarantee charge. Only $1.13 billion of it was distributed into workers’ funds, about $1,243 per worker.

The Tax Office sent 97,830 prompts to employers it believed had missed a payment or a lodgment date. Those prompts produced $467.3 million. That is more than double the $206 million of the year before. Its 12,050 audit and review cases raised $700.4 million, about $58,000 per case against about $4,800 per prompt. Firmer and legal actions, director penalty notices, garnishee notices and court proceedings among them, fell from 22,550 to 18,410 while the total raised rose 28 percent. Employers also came forward on their own: voluntary disclosures produced about $619 million, up from about $548 million the year before, more than a quarter of everything raised.

Deputy Commissioner Ben Kelly said paying the super workers are entitled to is non-negotiable. Nearly 93 percent of super guarantee obligations are met without any Tax Office intervention. The snapshot’s arithmetic closes on the $2.22 billion: prompts brought $467.3 million, cases $700.4 million, disclosures $619 million, penalties $248 million and interest $184 million.

Of the 945,600 employers in the country, 81,100 still have a collectable super guarantee debt. Sixteen percent of them, about 13,000 employers, owe 60 percent of it. That is about $1.58 billion. The total collectable debt works out at about $2.63 billion, and the $271 million sitting under payment plans is 10.3 percent of it, with only about 9,100 employers on such a plan at all.

A worker posting on Reddit as u/KnaidelHead in October described the other side of that ledger. His wife is pregnant. She is due in April 2027, and his employer stopped paying his super, leaving about six months missing. A payment in October covered one quarter only. “I’ve submitted the ATO unpaid super enquiry form twice (anonymously), but honestly, it feels like nothing is happening,” he wrote. Some employees in higher positions than his had their super paid, he wrote, while others, including him, had been left waiting.

Another worker, u/bupe_strip, is a concreter. He posted in September, four years into the job, and wrote that the boss had spent 18 months promising to sort his super and tax. “For the last 18 months he has been promising to sort my super and tax, this is the longest I’ve ever had a job so what he owes me in super is more than double what I have already,” he wrote. He had filed a report with the Tax Office. He asked whether it sometimes takes years. “This arsehole has a front yard full of luxury vehicles,” he wrote.

Craig Potter, commenting on the Fair Work Ombudsman’s post about its own 2025–26 recovery figures in late October, put the same wait in plainer terms. “Told us we were right but wait for employer to pay outstanding wages. 2.5 years and nothing. Said to pursue our own legal channels as Fair Work Ombudsman weren’t interested in helping any further.” Kelly describes a system that works. The workers posting about their own cases describe waiting instead: a certificate in hand, no money in the fund. Richard Whitten, a money expert at Finder, put the workers’ half of it in one line: “Super is part of your pay. It isn’t a perk or an optional extra.”

The Tax Office’s own net super guarantee gap for 2023–24 is 6.1 percent, or $7.25 billion, up from $6.25 billion the year before. The $1.13 billion distributed in 2025–26 is 15.6 percent of one year’s gap, the same share Finder put at about 15 percent of unpaid super ever recovered. The Super Members Council’s analysis of Tax Office data puts about 3.4 million workers, 28 percent of employees, as underpaid in 2023–24. The average shortfall was $1,850 each. About 909,000 got money back last year, roughly one in four of the underpaid.

The snapshot states that its results do not include Payday Super statistics. The reform, under which super must reach a fund within seven business days of payday, only commenced on 1 July 2026. The $1.13 billion is old-system money, recovered under quarterly rules that let a missed payment sit for months before anyone had to act. Workers who think they are owed can report it through the Tax Office’s online unpaid super tool, and the Tax Office says it will tell them by letter or email if it manages to collect. The $2.22 billion includes $184 million of interest, which the Tax Office pays into workers’ funds along with the shortfall.